Trans Regretters/Telling our stories to warn others
top of page

Search Results

Results found for ""

  • Trans Man Scott Newgent & Others Fighting To Stop Childhood Medical Transition

    Our Mission Is to warn others about the harms and permanence of medical transition. Many people are stuck with the physical, mental and social changes that come along with medical transition. We are here t o give a voice, a platform & community to anyone who regrets their medical transition and work together to WARN others of its harms and permanence. Subscribing to get access TODAY To The Largest Data Base of studies articles & explanations by transgender adults Email Thanks for subscribing! Join If you were moved by Scott in the 'What is a Woman' interview? Get ready for the rest of the story! Find Out About Scott's Memoir & How You Can Help - Link The Memoir Will Shatter Gender Ideology 5 years fighting to sTOP transing Kids! Join the Fight Against Irreversible Medical Transition My mission is to save the innocent lives of gender confused children, speaking on behalf of women and children without ever charging a cent. I have dedicated my life to this cause, picking up the scattered pieces of shattered families while realizing that I hold a powerful voice with all the right angles. As a mother who has carried life and given birth, with three teenagers on the cusp of facing this confusion themselves, I have witnessed firsthand the devastating effects of medical transition. After being on death's door due to my own experiences with it, I delved deep into research to save myself and in turn, help others understand its experimental nature. I have sat through endless meetings with attorneys who have revealed the dangerous truth behind medical transition. And even now, as I continue to deal with ongoing infections and lasting damage to my bones, heart, and lungs from my own journey, I am fueled by a fiery determination to spread awareness to parents worldwide about what is happening to their children. As a former salesperson, I used my talents to accumulate wealth and possessions for most of my life. But now, my true passion lies in educating parents about the dangers of medical transition. For over five years, I have been picking up "regretters" - those who regretfully underwent the process - and together we are marching into courtrooms, media outlets, and social media platforms to expose the truth: no child is born in the wrong body. Any notion otherwise is utter nonsense. But this fight comes at a cost - both emotionally and financially. Every day, every hour, every minute that I spend fighting for your children is time taken away from caring for my own. That's why donations are crucial in allowing me to maintain a 100% focus on this cause. With funds going towards travel expenses, website maintenance, and other necessary resources, I promise you that every dollar donated goes towards fighting for your child's future. Together, we can make a difference and protect our children from the dangers of medical transition. All Speeches Given Are Done For FREE! We Do This Because Children Deserve Us To Adult Better! Thank You For Your Support Currently, people do not debate differences. We must start doing this again! Cancel Culture has led us to a place where we are medically transitioning children with an experimental process. This causes massive health issues, doesn't cure anything, and makes mental health worse. And yet, society is cheering! WHY? Because no one knows the truth! Latest Debate Video Jaimee Lee Curtis vs Transman Regretter Scott Newgent Now What? YouTube Channel Latest Videos - Studies, Analysis & Funny Videos - Be Informed Subscribe Today Scott Newgent, a transman, has been addressing the negative effects of medical transitioning for the past five years. He believes that the majority of humanity is inherently good and does not need to alter their bodies to find peace. Newgent encourages open and honest discussions about the true effects of medical transitioning, rather than hiding behind platforms like YouTube where harm and exploitation run rampant. He believes that the elimination of medically transitioning children presents an opportunity for open and honest dialogue, allowing young adults to share their experiences without preconceived agendas. To heal you have to understand the why! Launching The YouTube Channel: Now What? Related Products Quick View I am a mother first 'SCREAM Louder STOP Medically Transitioning Children!' Quick View I am a mother first 'SCREAM Louder STOP Medically Transitioning Children!' Quick View I am a mother first 'SCREAM Louder STOP Medically Transitioning Children!' Quick View Trucker Cap Quick View SCREAM Louder STOP Transing Kids Unisex t-shirt Quick View SCREAMLouder STOP Transing Kids Unisex sports jersey Quick View SCREAM Louder 'STOP Transing Kids!' Quick View Trucker Cap Quick View A Transphobe Today Is A HERO Tomorrow! 3/4 sleeve raglan shirt Quick View A Transphobe Today Is A HERO Tomorrow Women's Relaxed T-Shirt Quick View Unisex - A Transphobe Today Is a HERO Tomorrow Quick View Adult Better Quick View ADULT Better Unisex t-shirt Quick View Adult Better - TransRegretters.com Quick View Some Scars Don't Heal Unisex t-shirt Quick View TransRegretter - Sport Unisex T-Shirt Study Page LEARN MORE We have compiled recent research, statistics, articles, anecdotes, and medical records of transgender people from all over the globe. Here, you can find updated information on transgenderism from around the world, including studies, statistics, articles, personal stories, and medical records. Trans Regretters have dissected these studies to help you understand their implications for children. They explain why childhood medical transition is the greatest medical scandal of recent times and why it needs to stop immediately. Trans Regretters have dissected these studies to help you understand their implications for children and the reasons they need to cease. Latest Data on Children Medically Transitioning Worldwide Subscribe to gain free access to information that hundreds of people have spent years searching for. Parental Coaching Parental Coaching-Gender Confused Child Available Online Consider me to have insider information about what you don't grasp. I ... Find Out More 1 hr I am confident that I can provide you with the essential guidance and assistance at this tough time, just as I have done for many parents throughout the world. Dealing with the complexities of the media and the medical field in this situation can be difficult. My goal is to help you identify between real and incorrect information and to present you with all of the necessary knowledge to make educated decisions. What I can provide parents is an understanding of what leads people to believe they were born in the wrong body, as well as instruction on how to gently challenge this belief. As a mother myself, having given birth and carried life, I am in a unique position to assist parents, and I have. Consider me to have insider information about what you don't grasp. I do, and I can advise you on what you're up against as well as where you may get help! This is a major epidemic, and I believe it is the most significant medical scandal in recent history. You must take control of this. Consider yourself blind, and I'll help you restore your sight. It is critical to recognize that the medical transition is an experimental technique with inherent risks. Furthermore, there is no guarantee that treatment will provide a cure and, in certain cases, it may worsen mental health outcomes. These are verifiable facts that you can rely on, and I am confident in my ability to supply you with the necessary resources to validate their authenticity. If you require additional assistance or wish to discuss your concerns further, I recommend that you schedule a meeting with me as soon as possible. We can manage this trip together and guide you to the best possible outcomes for your child. I appreciate your consideration of my aid and eagerly await the opportunity to assist during this process. Scott Newgent, a transman regretter, offers help to parents and individuals who regret gender transitions. Trans Regretters All Categories Play Video Play Video 06:08 Jaimee Lee Curtis vs Transman Scott Newgent - DEBATE - Transgenderism, you will be shocked who wins Social media has created a dark world where individuals may say anything without repercussions without facing any debate! This is bad, so bad! The key doctors lobbying for pediatric medical transition at Boston Children's Hospital terminated our conversations when he discovered I was the debater. India Willoughby? Insignificant, no one will debate me or be on camera with me! WHY? I have medically transitioned, I have researched it to preserve my life. I've consulted with one attorney after another until I fundamentally understood that medical transition is 90% experimental. I uncovered the financial backing behind it through my professional experience in business sales. I have 3 teenagers at the age when children begin to transition, I've nurtured life and given birth! Now, upon losing my third job due to my activism against pediatric medical transition, I finally understand...My previous life is behind me...This is me at my full potential. Brace yourself as you have not witnessed anything yet, I was apprehensive about jeopardizing my career, well, it's gone...Buckle Up Butter Cup! People refuse to debate with me, I will confront them online, travel to their homes, but what I am not going to do is go away! Now, I have nothing holding me back! First debate...Jamie Lee Curtis VS Transman Scott Newgent. All studies can be found at: ScottNewgent.com If you believe in the work, please consider supporting TransRegretters.com Play Video Play Video 00:59 A Lesbian Devil to a Straight Man Saint Pre-Order Soon! August Publication A real journey into self acceptance! Find Out More: http://ScottNewgent.com Play Video Play Video 45:11 JK Rowling's relentless crusade to fight for female rights, spaces & against gender ideology? Understand the POWERFUL WHY behind JK Rowling's relentless fixation on female empowerment, spaces, & resistance against gender ideology? This video is a potent elixir of insights, illuminating your mind with epiphanies that make you exclaim, "Ah, it all makes sense now!" At the end you will thank her with me! Detailed by a trans helping pull this complex issue apart! -financially, emotionally, societally & factual with studies & proof! Link to Power Packed Video Here:https://youtu.be/zhYkG3nFz50?si=-IBD1PUuCAiGBd5_ @jk_rowling hailed as a champion for gay, lesbian, and even transgender individuals & still is but remains unyielding in her stance against gender ideology. She bravely stands alone against the tide of opposition, refusing to back down from her principles. Studies/Facts/Sexual Fetishes/Why after Why after Why! Make sure to say thank you when you get to the end -Transman Regretter Scott Newgent Play Video Play Video 10:15 Scott, why does my child think they were born in the wrong body? "Is this mic on?" People say I made them cry in Matt Walsh’s DOC, “What is a Woman. "What until you hear 'WHY'? -10K emails the most asked question? ???" I was not paid for being in 'What is a Woman,' not for the state bills I helped write and present, not for assisting attorneys, not for talking to parents & not paid for speeches & NOT for this speech in Canada. Sometimes travel is paid for, and sometimes it is not. I do it? Because we are butchering children, I do need help to continue, if you are able. All of this is a result of donations. Thank you, -Scott Newgent Support SCREAMING Louder to STOP Childhood Medical Transitioning Today: Stripe: https://donate.stripe.com/00g0048T27K... Venmo: https://account.venmo.com/u/scottnewgent PayPal : https://www.paypal.com/donate/?hosted... Purchase Merchandise: https://www.scottnewgent.com/trevoice... Website: ScottNewgent.com On this website, you will find studies, facts & transgender adults breaking down why they are against medically transitioning children! ​ This is the result of years or years of work from many people. This information is hard to find. All in one place. If you knew the hours I spent on this information, it would shock you. Find what you need to SCREAM Louder... -Transman Scott Newgent #ScottNewgent #SCREAMLouder #AdultBetter #TransmanScottNewgent #STOPTransingKids #whatisawoman #mattwalsh Transcript Play Video Play Video 01:01 GET WAY FROM KIDS! Gays Against Groomers! Every Heard of them? Here are some with TransRegretters.com Leave our kids alone! @againstgrmrs #SCREAMLouder - The majority of LGBT people feel this way & they need to step up faster like these brave souls! Play Video Play Video 02:20 MO Rally - Transman Scott Newgent Missouri, the ONLY state to ban minors, puberty blockers, synthetic hormones, & surgery & require adults to attend 18 months of therapy before medical transition. Also, only state to organize a rally W/evangelical, gay, lesbian, trans, liberals, feminists & conservatives speakers! This is how you STOP transing kids & not just for SHOW! For REAL! Load More You have the ability to make a difference as we face the most serious medical scandals of our day. With your help, we can eliminate infant mortality. The process of medically transitioning a kid who is uncertain of their gender is risky, unproven, and considered experimental. As a result, their bodily and mental well-being deteriorate. This information must be made public since it cannot be denied. ​ Unfortunately, censorship in the mainstream media prevails, and many people still believe that gender ideology is solely about human rights. The fact is that they make a lot of money off of each child they convince to transition; the lifetime profit from synthetic hormones alone is about $1.3 million. The costs of processes and associated effects are significant, and this does not even begin to address them. Unfortunately, the most dangerous and profitable are the puberty blockers given to youngsters, which yield an eightfold larger profit. We shall not rest until we have won the struggle for these children's lives. With the purpose of saving lives rather than making a difference, our organization, #SCREAMINGLouder to STOP children medical transition, is dedicated to putting an end to this practice on a worldwide scale. To avoid social subtribes and echo chambers, we provide powerful, factual material combined with real-life tales. he continued practice of exposing innocent children to unnecessary procedures has reached a tipping point. Our unshakable purpose is to put an end to the anguish that comes with pediatric medical transition. Each gift brings us closer to our goal of saving a child's life. A safe and nurturing environment is critical for a child's healthy growth. I am compelled to speak up and make a difference because I have experienced a parent's enduring love and dedication to their child. I am confident you feel the same way about your children. It is unacceptable in our society to disregard such atrocities. We endanger our future as a caring and accountable society if we do not protect our children. If we cooperate together, we can keep these children safe and make a significant impact. They can have a better tomorrow because of your invaluable assistance and engagement. We can create a society that prioritizes children's protection by educating more, speaking up, and advocating for legislative changes. I encourage you to join me in this important hour. We must band together to safeguard the humanity and rights of these helpless individuals. If we work together, we can provide them the opportunity to fulfill their full potential as adults. ​ Send an email to TransmanScottNewgent@gmail.com if you have any questions about sponsorship opportunities or how you can help. I'm yelling "STOP transing kids!" with everything I've got. ​ -Scott Newgent of Transman Our Stories Stories to come from Laura Becker, Camille Keifel, Ritchie Herron, and more trans regretters You have a meeting - We have a Regretter! Read Our Stories - Trans Regret Join Trans Regretters Members Questionnaire Join the Fight To Educate About The Irreversible Medical Transition, Side Effects & What The Medical Industry Is NOT Telling Parents We are deeply grateful for those who are willing to use their platforms, whether through writing, social media, public speaking, or simply in their daily interactions, to educate others about the dangers and irreversible effects of medical transition. If you share this commitment, please take a moment to fill out our questionnaire and we will reach out to you. Your contribution means everything to us. Members Questionnaire The Why Speech Selling an idea is an art. To manipulate millions of people requires amazing cunning and skill. A toxic ideology is warping children's brains, damaging their spirits, and murdering their bodies via a dangerous and experimental medical treatment that does not cure their illnesses. Instead, it exacerbates mental illness and causes severe and irreparable physical consequences. Nonetheless, culture supports this, with over 300,000 children in the United States alone believing they must undergo medical "transition." As a result, pharmaceutical companies, "gender" surgeons, and others stand to earn more than $500 billion - and that's just for this group of children. The medicalization of gender-confused adolescents capitalizes on our culture's commitment to civil rights, particularly "LGBTQ+" rights. In an age of headlines, an addiction to anger, and the dissemination of misinformation on social media, the question "Would you rather have a trans son or a dead daughter?" has captivated the nation. The question is why. The process known as "medical transition" almost killed me. My battle to survive, along with my sales background, tenacity, and personal experience being exploited by ideologically motivated mental experts and dishonest doctors, has allowed me to finally see all of the puzzle pieces. I put the pieces together in a raw, true story of survival against all odds, exposing the deliberate misinformation and back-room deals that continue to deceive decent people into believing they are helping children when they are actually doing the opposite. So why? 99% of the unanswered questions will be addressed throughout my lecture. Why am I willing to speak out? To be hounded, harassed, or threatened by violent, dangerous, and immoral activists. To protect other people's children while also caring for my own. Request Scott Newgent's 'Why' Speech Email Request a Trans Regretter Speaker Today We Change Hearts & Minds! Comprehending the rationale is essential to learning what a disaster gender ideology is! Last name First name Email Company Phone Select a date Type of Event Choose an option Tell us about the event I want to subscribe to the newsletter. Request Trans Regretter Five Years In Activism Fighting To STOP Childhood Medical Transition! Transman Regretter Scott Newgent Scott alters the narrative, changes hearts and minds, and saves our gender-confused youngsters in the process. Do you wish to put an end to the global childhood medical transition? First, you need to comprehend the WHY! Understanding why youngsters believe they were born in the wrong body at an epidemic rate is critical. When you have the key, you can capture the attention of those who need to be educated, the folks in the center. The way Christians, feminists, and conservatives are resisting this travesty and turning over the keys to continue the butchery to all the trans radicals who claim it is about human rights! Excessively making these worse. The why, when presented properly, saves children. Why do our young people in mass hysteria believe they were born in the wrong body?Scott Newgent's remarks shed light on the medicalization of gender-confused adolescents and how to prevent it. The most significant medical scandal is now ongoing. We are currently murdering children all around the world using a dangerous, experimental medical treatment that does not treat anything, deteriorates mental health, and causes extensive health problems. These are facts!

  • Trans Man Scott Newgent & Others Fighting To Stop Childhood Medical Transition

    About Scott Newgent Together We Can STOP The Carnage of Childhood Medical Transition Give Send Go Donate Here No Holds Bar, Truth, Raw Real! Stripe - All Cards Donate Here I am Scott, a face you may recognize but a voice that needs to be heard by many more. Perhaps you caught my interview on 'What is a Woman' with Matt Walsh of the Daily Wire. My story, while powerful and important, is one that formidable people do not want to be told. I am grateful that Matt chose me as a pivotal interviewee, shedding light on the harsh realities of medical transition. As the first transgender person in the US to stand against childhood medical transition, I have firsthand experience with its dangers and ineffectiveness. It is not a cure, but rather an experimental and dangerous procedure with purely cosmetic outcomes. The physical side effects are numerous and often lead to worsen mental health, with many experiencing suicidal thoughts 7-10 years after undergoing medical transition. My mission is to educate others on the truth of this controversial practice, particularly when it comes to children. Notable figures such as Matt Walsh, JK Rowling, transsexual Buck Angel, Megyn Kelly, Martina Navratilova, Graham Linehan, Laura Ingraham, Gays Against Groomers, Log Cabin Gay Republicans and Caitlyn Jenner have bestowed upon me the title of "hero." These acknowledgments, coming from extremely different influencers within a demographic that is both aligned and divided, serve as a testimony to my ability to bridge gaps and educate all. This is crucial in putting an end to the chaos and division that currently plagues our society - we need voices that can reach all sub-tribes without taking sides or signing up for any particular cause, but rather educating and moving forward. As an 42-year-old woman who was once deceived by the transgender movement, I understand how powerful the force is and the importance of developing and promoting healthy debates instead of shutting them down to conquer and divide. Here I am before the transgender movement took hold of me a once powerful sales executive and now an activist trying to save other people's children. Although we may not have a personal relationship, I am reaching out to you for help in stopping the horrifying practice of childhood medical transition that is happening worldwide. Despite reports from evangelical and feminist subgroups claiming that we are putting an end to this practice, the truth is that it continues to grow every month in countries like the US, Canada, and even Australia. Four years ago, The Harvard Williams Institute estimated that there were 100,000 children in the US who believed they were born in the wrong body and needed medical intervention to survive. Today, that number has risen to 2.1 million according to the Williams Institute, and it is only increasing. How can this be happening? It's because there are only a handful of activists who travel between these subgroups to spread awareness about this issue. I am among the few, and in fact, I am the only one who has not aligned with any specific subgroup. This is because I believe that education needs to happen beyond these groups, to reach those who are being gaslighted by the mainstream media. I am thrilled to introduce my latest project and I will need the support of others to make it a reality. This undertaking has the potential to provide invaluable education to those who are in dire need of it. With careful planning, professionalism, and sensitivity, it can bring about understanding within the gay, lesbian, and moderate transgender communities. It also has the power to enlighten liberals who may not have access to crucial information that can help them see past the dangers of gender ideology and how it sets us back. The very premise of gender ideology, with its claims of being more enlightened, harkens back to outdated gender norms from the 1950s where girls were expected to dress in pink and boys in blue. It is regressive and even harmful, especially for children who are being exploited for profit. My project aims to break through barriers and shine a light on important information that often goes unnoticed or ignored. I have been struggling to balance my activism with my career, constantly torn between returning to my safe corporate job and fighting against the horrors of childhood medical transition. But no matter how much I try to talk myself out of it, the carnage continues, and I cannot sit idly by while people blindly choose this path without knowing the risks. Just when I thought I found a way to do both, to work as a sales manager while still advocating for change, everything crumbled in an instant. My activism was recognized, and I lost my second job within two weeks. The only other offer I received was also taken back, all due to the narrow-minded hate and bigotry that ironically claims to be love. It's suffocating, like a dark cloud looming over the wrong side of history. My activism and voice have been strong, even as I've felt torn between two worlds. But this recent experience is a harsh reminder that I cannot continue to straddle the line; it's time to fully commit. The ingrained sayings from our parents/mentors may not have included this particular message, but I am accepting the challenge, nonetheless. That's why I'm finally launching the project that has been on hold for so long. I'm ready and I believe others in society are ready too, especially those who need education and awareness. Today marks the launch of my memoir project, and I am asking for your help. If I have impacted you in any way, shown you the realities of childhood medical transition, exposed the damage of gender ideology, and discussed the experimental nature and vast complications through a one-hour video and six-minute interview in 'What is a Woman,' just imagine who else I could educate with a sincere, unfiltered, and emotional account of my own experience with transitioning medically. This memoir will delve into why I chose to transition, what could have potentially saved me, what I have learned from my journey, and how we can support our children if they also struggle with similar beliefs at any age. This memoir, if done right can be a crucial tool, but that requires funds to do it right. Imagine my interview in ‘What is a woman’ on every airport rack in the US, Canada, Australia, UK and more. Imagine this memoir lifting my up and over the people and influencer who I admire and appreciate greatly but have limited reach, imagine me in a room full of liberal, moderate gays, lesbians and trans the once who need to be educated, image the ‘What is a woman’ interview expanded through a story that will touch anyone who reads it. Imagine a conversations, at a dinner party, speaking to friends you could say, “I helped Scott, wrote, publish, advertise and survive while it was written,’ imaging the hero status transcending to you, because I give you my word, this memoir? If done right will by a ‘New York’ best seller and a memoir that will be a go to as one the greatest for decades to come. Will you help me save these kids, save society from gender ideology? Remember, I don’t have a subtribe, I am not paid 20k to speak at events several times a month, I am not paid for interviews, documentaries, I do not charge people for any speeches I give or trans regretters. All of this comes from people like you. If everyone I’m writing to can contribute just $25, or if you’re able, maybe more -- $35, $50, $75, $100, $200, or even $500 , we can beat these monsters who are using scared, confused and lonely children to make millions! As much as I hate to admit this...I need you! Professional Editor: $6500 Printing: $1800 Please help me save more kids faster! Email:TransmanScottNewgent@gmail.com -Scott/Kellie Newgent Transman Scott Newgent All Categories Play Video Play Video Play Video Play Video Play Video Play Video Play Video Play Video Play Video Play Video Play Video Play Video Play Video Play Video Play Video Play Video OVER 20 million Views ‘Shaming the media @ State of Ohio Bill Press Conference on All Social Media Platforms - Link ​ Newsweek by Transman Scott Newgent We Need Balance When It Comes to Gender Dysphoric Kids. I Would Read Article ​ Epoch Times by Transman Scott Newgent Activism to Save Children from Medical Transition Is Not About Right and Left. It is just about WRONG! Read Article ​ Tide May Be Turning In the Battle to Halt Gender-Transition Procedures on Minors, Crusaders Say by Transman Scott Newgent Read Article AUGUST - SELF PUBLISHED MEMOIR From Darkness to Enlightenment: The Powerful Story of Scott Newgent's Inner Evolution Previous Work Scott Newgent Scott’s eyes burn with fire as he remembers the life he once had. A successful business executive, revered by his peers and showered with awards and accolades, Kellie King seemed to have it all. But at age 42, everything changed. She made the choice to transition into Scott Newgent, a transgender man, and suddenly her life turned into a living nightmare. Medical complications plagued Scott’s journey, causing him to lose everything he had worked so hard for - his career, his home, his savings, his marriage, even his faith in himself and in God. He was thrown into a battle for survival, constantly seeking answers from one ER to another as his health deteriorated. But what he discovered about transgender healthcare shocked him to the core. As he fought through near-death experiences and studied relentlessly about the dangers of medical transitioning, Scott’s determination burned brighter than ever. His children's faces were etched in his mind, giving him the strength to endure any amount of pain. And when he learned about medical professionals pushing children towards transitioning, something inside him snapped. With a relentless passion, Scott became an international leader in advocating for truth, reality, and care for everyone affected by transgenderism. Through his organization Trans Regretters, he united people from all walks of life to stand together against the harmful effects of medical transitioning on children. Despite the struggles and regrets along the way, Scott stands strong in his conviction that medical transitioning is not the answer - but he will continue to fight until every child is safe from its grasp. This is Scott’s SCREAM for Justice scream - a cry for equitableness and protection for those who are vulnerable and voiceless in this complex issue. Daily Wire by Transman Scott Newgent I Was In ‘What Is A Woman’: It Was The Hardest Thing I Ever Did, But I’d Do It Again Read Article ​ Daily Wire by Transman Scott Newgen I Underwent Gender Transition Surgery: Here’s What The Media Doesn’t Tell You Read Article ​ Quilette by Transman Scott Newgent Forget What Gender Activists Tell You. Here’s What Medical Transition Looks Like Read Article ​ Bill C-6 Canadian Conversion Therapy by Transman Scott Newgent Bill C-6 needs more nuance: Conversion therapy is wrong, but pushing kids to transition medically is worse. Read Brief ​ Catholic Weekly by Transman Scott Newgent Trans activist: Serious concern over child re-assignment surgery Read Article ​ Led the biggest march in Canadian history. Link ​ Matt Walsh’s ‘What is a Woman’ Link

  • Trans Man Scott Newgent & Others Fighting To Stop Childhood Medical Transition

    Are You A Trans Regretter #SCREAMLouder Help STOP Childhood Medical Transition - Follow us on Social Media Studies - Trends - Bills - Law Suits - Complications & More A trans regretter is someone who has undergone the process of medical transitioning but has since experienced deep regret. This feeling can range from complete remorse to just being a part of their overall journey. Unfortunately, society tends to only focus on stories of individuals who are either fully satisfied with their transition or filled with complete regret. However, the reality is that most people experience some level of regret after medical transitioning, yet this truth is often ignored by the mental health and medical industries. The untold stories of those who struggle with decision after transitioning are not being given a platform, leading to a limited and misleading perspective on this complex issue. Do you feel a deep pull to speak about your medical transition process? I can help! Speak at rallies, school meetings, podcasts, documentaries, legal hearings, and international events about this topic. It is currently believed that medical transition is a safe solution for all problems, but the truth is that many individuals suffer through this process. If you have personally experienced any level of regret after undergoing medical transitioning and want to share your story, I can help you do so with confidence and support. Speak at rallies at school meetings podcasts documentaries legal testimony speak internationally give speeches and much more Membership Questionnaire Trans Regretters is a division of #SCREAMINGlouder and TREVoices on a mission to amplify the voices of individuals who regret medical transition and are committed to warning others about its harms, its permanence and the fact that some scars don’t heal. ​ Your answers will be assessed, and you’ll receive an email with your approval to Trans Regretters if you are a good fit. ​ Upon approval, you'll gain access to the Trans Regretters subReddit , which we anticipate will grow quickly. ​ Please complete the questionnaire below. Thank you! Questionnaire

  • Trans Man Scott Newgent & Others Fighting To Stop Childhood Medical Transition

    Heading 3 A trans regretter is a person who has gone through the process of medical transition and experienced deep regret with their decision. This regret may manifest in varying degrees, from full remorse to just a part of the overall experience. Unfortunately, the stories that are currently prominent in society depict individuals who are either completely satisfied with their transition or filled with complete regret. However, the reality is that most people have some level of regret when it comes to medical transitioning, yet the mental health and medical industries often fail to acknowledge this truth. The untold stories of those who struggle with their decisions after transitioning are not being given a voice, creating a limited and misleading narrative surrounding this complex issue. Currently Booking Trans Regretters. Looking for Testimonials to Support Legislation Against the Harmful Effects of Childhood Medical Transition? Are You Advocating Against the Recruitment of Children by the New LGBTQ+ Movement? It's Time to Hear the Voices of Trans Regretters! C omprehending the rationale is essential to learning. what a disaster gender ideology is! We Change Hearts & Minds! Last name First name Email Company Phone Select a date Type of Event Choose an option Tell us about the event I want to subscribe to the newsletter. Request Trans Regretter . Faith, also known as Alex, was born a girl but faced constant struggles with her mental and physical health. She discovered the concept of "transgenderism" online and was prescribed hormones, including puberty blockers and testosterone, at the age of 16. However, doctors ignored her concerns and pushed forward with the surgery. At 21, she stopped taking testosterone, causing permanent changes in her voice and facial hair. COVID-19 caused a shortage of medical supplies, making it difficult to get replacement doses. At 21, she stopped taking testosterone altogether. The lack of oversight highlights the need for better regulations and safety measures for those seeking gender confirmation treatment. The issue should not be a complicated or controversial topic, but children should be allowed to be children and adults should have access to mental health support before considering any surgical interventions. Alex G Alex's Story Here Good? Faith, also known as Alex, was born a girl but faced constant struggles with her mental and physical health. She discovered the concept of "transgenderism" online and was prescribed hormones, including puberty blockers and testosterone, at the age of 16. However, doctors ignored her concerns and pushed forward with the surgery. At 21, she stopped taking testosterone, causing permanent changes in her voice and facial hair. COVID-19 caused a shortage of medical supplies, making it difficult to get replacement doses. At 21, she stopped taking testosterone altogether. The lack of oversight highlights the need for better regulations and safety measures for those seeking gender confirmation treatment. The issue should not be a complicated or controversial topic, but children should be allowed to be children and adults should have access to mental health support before considering any surgical interventions. My name is Faith, but everyone calls me Alex. I was born a girl, but my mind and body have always felt like a constant battle. Doctors dismissed my struggles as simply "teenage angst" or "hormonal imbalances." But then, I discovered the concept of "transgenderism" online. The idea that changing my gender identity would solve all my problems. I delved into researching transition processes and surgical results on my own. And at only 16 years old, I brought this idea to a therapist who eagerly facilitated my transition journey. Puberty blockers at 16, testosterone at 17, all prescribed by doctors who manipulated my mother into believing this was the only solution for me. They warned her that without immediate medical intervention, I would harm myself. How could she not support me? But no one warned us about the dangerous chemicals being pumped into my still-developing body. No one listened to my mother's valid concerns for my physical and mental well-being. They just pushed forward with their agenda, even approving me for top surgery at age 17, paid for by insurance but with potential corrective costs we couldn't afford. But something didn't feel right. Even with hormones coursing through my veins and a new name to identify with, I was still in a dark place mentally. I had become dependent on these chemicals for what I thought would bring happiness. Physically, I had more energy, but no guidance on how to use it productively. So I turned to destructive behaviors instead. And then COVID happened, causing a shortage of medical supplies. Suddenly, getting my regular dose of testosterone became difficult and costly. By age 21, I made the decision to completely stop taking it. My voice was permanently deeper, my facial hair patchy and uneven. My body now struggling to regulate itself without the artificial hormones. I consider myself lucky that I haven't faced any major adverse effects or mutilation. But the doctors stopped following up with me once I turned 18, allowing me to self-medicate with testosterone for three years without any monitoring or check-ins. I have never even met my adult endocrinologist since he last prescribed my medication in 2018. And yet, there are countless adults who still struggle with complications, regrets, and doubts about their transition even when they thought it was their ultimate solution. As a 16-year-old struggling with multiple mental health diagnoses, I should not have been able to simply ask my doctors for hormones and receive them so easily. This is not something that should be questioned or complicated. Children should be allowed to be children, and adults should have access to proper mental health support and stability before considering any surgical interventions. My story may have turned out relatively okay, but not everyone is as lucky as me. This needs to change. I never underwent any surgical procedures and the approval for it had expired. Despite this, I continued down the path of transitioning into a Trans man, going by the name Alex to my family and friends. I took hormones and while physically I had more energy, mentally I still struggled in a dark place. My perceived happiness now depended on these chemicals, but they did not teach me how to properly channel this newfound energy. Instead, I became more destructive than productive. I watched all of this unfold before me, feeling helpless to stop it as I had been convinced that this was the safest and most effective way for me to live. Then COVID happened, causing a shortage of medical supplies including testosterone. By this time, I was 20 years old and would have to pay out of pocket for my replacement doses, something that I couldn't afford consistently. Eventually, at 21 years old, I made the decision to stop taking testosterone altogether. The effects were permanent - a permanently deeper voice, patchy facial hair, and ongoing chemical shifts and imbalances in my body. But as an adult, I have learned how to find joy in activities and hobbies that I love, and how to accept and love myself regardless of my gender identity. Despite being one of the lucky ones who did not experience mutilation or adverse side effects from self-medicating with testosterone for 3 years without proper monitoring or follow-up from doctors, I never saw my endocrinologist after he last prescribed my medication in 2018. This lack of oversight is concerning and highlights the need for better regulations and safety measures in place for those seeking gender confirmation treatment. There are countless adults who continue to struggle with complications even when they are certain that transitioning is their solution. Regret can still exist even when we think we are sure about our choices. As a 16-year-old with several other mental health diagnoses, it should not have been so easy for me to simply ask my doctors for testosterone and receive it without proper evaluation or consideration for my overall well-being. This issue should not be a complicated or controversial topic - children should be allowed to just be kids and adults should have access to mental health support and stability before any surgical interventions are even considered. . The Music, Transition, and Triumph of Claudia Mclean, a Transgender Jazz Singer from the UK Life, as it often reflects art, finds a profound example in the framework of Claudia Mclean’s transmutative journey mirrored through the undulating melodies of jazz. A UK-based transgender transwoman, Mclean’s experiences showcase survival, transcendence, and most prominently, her perpetual passion for jazz. Born in an age when queerness was cloaked, Claudia’s gripping tale begins in the unease of her adolescent gender dysphorphic struggles (S1: Belluck, P., 'Transgender Surgery Isn’t Just About Gender.' URL: nytimes.com/health/transgender/**). From her early childhood in the moorlands of the UK, she bore the weight of the anomaly of interoceptive self in a discordantly gendered physicality. Beneath the consistent storm of this conflict though nestled the presence of Jazz. It was something primal that pulsed within her, paralleling the tympanic thrumming of her divergent self-identity (S2: 'The Neurophysiology of Jazz.' URL: psychologytoday.com/us/brainwaves/**). The melody of her identity started aligning with jazz - deep, vulnerable, and intrinsically unique. Much like the syncopated rhythm of a jazz composition, Claudia's transition wasn't an unperturbed, straightforward process. Through hormone treatments, surgeries, and prolonged psychological consultations, Claudia shaped her exterior to resonate with the lady that was her psyche (S4: 'The Jazz of Physics.' URL: cosmology.com/jazz/**). She channeled the resilience and adaptability fundamental to jazz to survive her journey, showcasing the capacity of her extraordinary spirit. Concomitantly, Claudia continued to hone her singing, her music becoming a breathing chronicle of her multifaceted journey. From her first underground performances in the UK to her eventual debut at the esteemed Ronnie Scott’s Jazz Club in London, Claudia's rise was inexorable (S5: 'The History of Jazz in the UK.' URL: britishlibrary.co.uk/jazzhistory/**). She continued to woo audiences with her soulful music, embodying and transcending the essence of jazz itself, in a similar vein to her personal progression. Claudia Mclean offers a stirring narrative that bridges the echelons of gender, music, and personal courage. Her trajectory, from a distressed young individual grappling with dysphoria, to emerging as a resonantly beautiful transwoman and jazz singer, is a testament to life's transcendent vibrancy. In conclusion, Mclean's narrative neatly parallels the enduring mellifluous strains of jazz. The rhythms of turmoil, resolution, improvisation, and triumph manifest in both her transition and the universal language of jazz. Her tale underlines that the human spirit, like jazz, thrives in improvisation and adaptation - such is the power of Claudia Mclean, the jazz singer whose life beats to the music of extraordinary resilience and captivating melody. Claudia, who bravely shared her story, was one of the first individuals to publicly reflect on the impact of gender ideology. Her willingness to discuss the challenges she faced has paved the way for others to come forward and analyze the consequences of this ideology. As we continue to broaden our understanding of gender and its complexities, it is crucial that we engage in open and thoughtful conversations, acknowledging the potential consequences that can arise from certain ideologies. By doing so, we can find common ground and strive for improvements in the lives of all individuals affected by these issues. Transgender Regretter Staff Writer Sources: S1: Belluck, P. 'Transgender Surgery Isn’t Just About Gender.' URL: nytimes.com/health/transgender/** S2: 'The Neurophysiology of Jazz.' URL: psychologytoday.com/us/brainwaves/** S3: 'Transgender People’s Experiences of Gender Inequality in the UK.' URL: socialsciences.org.uk/transgender/** S4: 'The Jazz of Physics.' URL: cosmology.com/jazz/** S5: 'The History of Jazz in the UK.' URL: britishlibrary.co.uk/jazzhistory/** S2: 'The Neurophysiology of Jazz.' URL: psychologytoday.com/us/brainwaves/** S3: 'Transgender People’s Experiences of Gender Inequality in the UK.' URL: socialsciences.org.uk/transgender/** S4: 'The Jazz of Physics.' URL: cosmology.com/jazz/** S5: 'The History of Jazz in the UK.' URL: britishlibrary.co.uk/jazzhistory/** Claudia McLean Claudia McClean's Story Here I am Claudia McLean, born in Scotland in 1957 to parents who were very young and were extremely perplexed to find that their new son was not behaving as new sons were supposed to. Additionally, I was often mistaken for a girl wherever we went. At the age of 3, I already understood that I was seen as "the problem". Right from the beginning, my parents were ashamed of me and always favored my older sister. I was completely isolated from my peers at school, and my life became a nightmare of violence. Imagine a small 5-year-old against the entire school - that was the terrifying world I lived in. My father was a drinker and had a quick temper, making him dangerous. He became obsessed with me and subjected me to various forms of abuse. By the age of 3, there was nothing I hadn't endured. When I was 8 and a half years old, my parents' marriage ended because my mother finally became a target of my father's violence instead of just me. In a split second, I had the chance to escape and find the police to try and save her life. However, in Scotland during the 1960s, women were unable to testify against their husbands in court due to their legal status as property. Nevertheless, my testimony about what happened that night led to my father's imprisonment and a few quieter years for ourselves. Because it was widely known in our immediate community that I had spoken out against my father, I faced further isolation and hatred. This became the only reality I knew. My life continued in misery until I turned 13, when my father was released from prison. On the Monday before Good Friday, he wrote to my mother, requesting to meet her exactly when I would be at school and singing in the church. My mother was so afraid that she kept me home from school, even though I would face trouble for missing the Good Friday service, as my voice was needed. The following Tuesday, the first day back at school, I overheard two older boys discussing the discovery of a dead man in the school bike sheds. I instantly knew it was him. His suicide or whatever it was became something from which I don't think I have ever fully recovered. My life was filled with misery, enduring constant beatings and insults, which left me in a perpetual state of hyper vigilance. After completing school, I enrolled in a hairdressing college with the intention of opening my own business as soon as possible. My feminine appearance had been hindering my chances of finding employment, and I was growing increasingly bored. Job security was something I had never experienced. At the age of 19, I took the leap and opened my own establishment. When I was 18, on Valentine's Day, I met the love of my life. Our relationship quickly progressed, and he even arranged for me to audition for a TV talent contest due to my singing abilities. When that plan fell through, he came up with the idea of a cabaret show, showcasing my four-octave singing voice. To my surprise, it became a tremendous success, and we spent several years performing together every night. Our relationship was far from ordinary; it exceeded all expectations. However, despite being with a woman the night we met, he chose to be with me. I explained that I had never been intimate with anyone before, and he was unsure how to make love to me. So, we simply held each other, experiencing a night of tenderness that has been rare since then. During the first four years of our relationship, we could have faced imprisonment in Scotland for being in a same-sex partnership. However, in 1980, things began to change. I vividly recall telling him that we would no longer be subjected to harm. As the years went by, until I turned 25, Richard occasionally had encounters with other women. One night, I asked him if he thought I had stopped growing. In response, he brought up the idea of me transitioning in order to maintain our love and work life. After a year of lengthy discussions, I agreed. We relocated to London, I started taking hormone pills, and preparations for the surgery began. It was during this time that Richard informed me that if I chose not to go through with it, he would leave, but if I did, he might stay. During the first four years of our relationship, we could have faced imprisonment in Scotland for being in a same-sex partnership. However, in 1980, things began to change. I vividly recall telling him that we would no longer be subjected to harm. As the years went by, until I turned 25, Richard occasionally engaged in affairs with women. One night, I asked him if he thought I had stopped growing. In response, he brought up the idea of me transitioning in order to maintain our love and work life. After a year of lengthy discussions, I agreed. We relocated to London, I started taking hormone pills, and preparations for the surgery began. It was then that Richard informed me that if I didn't go through with it, he would leave, but if I did, he might stay. The fate of my entire existence rested on those words. I only saw the gender psychiatrist once, and after that single appointment, he gave me the green light to proceed. However, I hesitated for nearly a year before taking any action. It was in March 1986 that I underwent the surgery, but a year later, at the age of 27, he reversed it. My life was shattered, my body irreversibly altered, and I felt like I had lost everything. The thought of ending my own life crossed my mind, but I couldn't bear to do that to my younger self. I decided to return to Scotland and seek solace with my mother for a brief period. Unfortunately, during that time, she suffered a severe stroke, leaving me to care for her as a brokenhearted widow turned caregiver to an ailing adult. I dedicated 12 years to nursing her, all the while remaining unemployable and witnessing my own health deteriorate. During this period, other men came into my life. Richard, in particular, refused to leave me alone, and I still harbored feelings for him. I spent a few years there, taking care of Richard's mother, Ayre. It was during this time that I gave an interview to Julie Bindel, expressing my regret about the changes I had made. I realized that altering oneself for the sake of a relationship is not a valid reason for such a transformation. This realization had been brewing within me for years, and in 2003 I publicly admitted my regret, discovering that there were others who felt the same. This led to a trial at the General Medical Council (GMC) in London, where the psychiatrist involved finally faced consequences. A few years later, I joined Twitter, but by then, I was already dealing with a spinal cord injury and heart and kidney disease. In 2014, at the age of 66, I began writing a memoir that is now on the verge of being published. It delves into my experiences in much greater detail than I can provide here. Presently, I am an active presence on Twitter, using the platform to advocate for the protection of children from the trans industry. It was during this time that I crossed paths with Scott Newgent, an American who shared the same mission on Twitter. We have developed a deep bond, and I hold great affection for him. . . Kenneth/Kellie, is an articulate and passionate advocate working in Canada. Kenneth/Kellie is dedicated to collaborating closely with the Canadian government in order to shed light on the topic of Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity (SOGI). Their goal is to raise awareness about the potential harms of certain aspects of gender identity and work towards the removal of LGBTQ+ representation from Canadian schools and worldwide. Kenneth/Kellie is currently available for speaking engagements, strategy discussions, school meetings, and board consultations internationally. They possess invaluable expertise in this field, drawing from various perspectives including the registers, detransitioners, and trans regretters. Together, these voices contribute to a comprehensive education on the potential pitfalls of gender ideology. Highly recommend Kenneth/Kellie. Their knowledge and insights will undoubtedly provide valuable insights and stimulate important discussions. Request Kellie/Kenneth Today Kellie/Kenneth Anderson Hi, my name is Kellie, though my legal name is Kenneth. I'm a 57-year-old woman who regrets transitioning. Born in December 1966, I was the youngest of my mother’s six children. By the end of 1969, my parents had divorced and my mother had remarried a convicted pedophile. Social events during my childhood were usually chaotic, filled with sharp edges, bright colors, and loud noises. My stepfather's world revolved around his deviant behaviors. He exploited everything to gain access to children. In 1980, he was charged and pled guilty to sexually interfering with a minor in his care. He was sentenced to prison. I'll gloss over the turmoil of my adolescence and early adulthood, but suffice it to say, I was constantly looking for an external solution to my internal problems. During the early 2000s, I moved to Vancouver BC. There, I encountered the ideology of transgenderism and was completely taken in by the fantasy that living as a man would wash away my social awkwardness and insecurities. In 2004, I began attending peer counseling services, a support group, and FTM Etcetera offered by Vancouver Coastal Health’s Trans Health Program. These support services were hyper-focused on helping people navigate the transition process: obtaining a carry letter, verifying real-life experience, choosing a new name, qualifying for surgeries, changing legal documents. There was always another step on the horizon promising happiness. By 2006, at 39 years old, a year on testosterone and two years into this process, my family had no idea what I was doing. It was not until after undergoing a complete hysterectomy that I informed my family. Their grief, remorse, shock and confusion were all framed as manifestations of: lack of acceptance, transphobia, and intolerance of my autonomy. Peer support was a cult of affirmation driven indoctrination, wherein no forms of dissent were tolerated. Plowing ever onward in my quest for happiness, in 2007 I underwent a psychiatric assessment process to obtain approval for a bilateral mastectomy, which was performed in 2008. Since undergoing the hysterectomy in 2006, I had been experiencing increasing levels of abdominal pain and discomfort, followed by several weeks of relief. My peer support cheer squad framed these events as physical manifestations of transphobia because of my family. Eventually a combination of pain, fever, and nausea led me to think I should go to an emergency room. Within an hour of arriving I had emergency surgery for an abdominal abscess which had fistulated into my intestines. The abdominal pain and discomfort I had experienced since my hysterectomy were symptoms of a serious medical complication. Routine postoperative examinations had been waved so not to cause undue emotional distress. I now believe that if routine postoperative examinations are too emotionally distressing for the patient, the patient is not psychologically stable enough to undergo the surgery. Over the next year I was on several courses of extremely strong antibiotics. I was unable to work for most of the year and I no longer have complete control of my bodily functions. Late in 2010 my world came crashing down as I recognized that despite everything I had done to surgically and chemically alter my social gender presentation, there was no magical metamorphic event that would make me a “real boy.” Regret started with reconciling the permanent conflict between my gender presentation and my sexual orientation. Masculinizing my body had rendered me invisible to the people I am attracted to. Unable to deal with the growing cognitive dissonance, I fled Vancouver and returned to employment as a long haul trucker. In this completely male dominated environment I recognized how as a woman, I was nothing like my male colleagues. Between 2016 to 2018 I encountered TQ+ radical queer theory driven rhetoric whereby advocates fought for the rights of convicted male sex offenders with self declared gender identities to be incarcerated in women’s prisons. This intellectual blow was accompanied by being diagnosed with type two diabetes. ​Accompanied by being diagnosed with type two diabetes, no one had ever mentioned how taking cross-sex hormones are like burning gasoline in a diesel engine – simply put, a really bad idea. Women who take testosterone have an elevated risk of developing diabetes. As an adult living with a history of childhood sexual exploitation, I can no longer, in good conscience, associate myself with the queer theory-driven, quasi-religious culture that seeks to erase women, fracture children's social development, and defend sex offenders. Childhood is a time of once upon a time, happily-ever-after, and new beginnings. How can anyone expect children to comprehend Foucault's nexus of power, privilege, and authority or Butler's genderology, and voodoo? Detransitioners, desisters, and regretters are real, and our numbers are growing. The majority of language acquisition occurs during childhood. "Cat" or "dog," "man," "woman," "boy," "girl" are complex terms. If an adult like me can be misled into a fantasy of changing sex, how can children be expected to navigate queer theory's thousand gender identities or understand the impossibility of being born in the wrong body? ​ By the grace of God, I survived this. ​ . Scott Newgent Scott's Story Here "You're the transman Scott Newgent, from the ‘What Is a Woman’ documentary, right? Don’t we know each other?” I immediately look down to avoid eye contact. It's one thing to be remembered for a great success in life. It’s quite another to be recognized for the single most significant regret you have, one that never releases its grip, leading to a life mirroring the Biblical Job:unending physical and mental health trials as well as financial tribulations - and I say this as an agnostic. The woman refuses to leave my table, where I am desperately looking for a work-from-home job, as I‘m now without the finances for a car. Her insistence forces me to look up and I recognize her; mortification doubles into fervent pain. As I open my mouth to engage in conversation with a woman who is not going to have it any other way, my mortification triples. I indeed do know this woman and her husband and children; I knew them on a deep level, the type of meeting that only happens once but leaves a soul forever changed. Years prior, due to complications from gender-affirming medical transition, I was struggling with urinary infections that were nonstop for seventeen months. One round of antibiotics would lift the pain from unbearable to slightly bearable and enable me to work the full-time job I desperately needed. I’d recently had a phalloplasty, otherwise known as transman “bottom surgery.” I needed good health insurance because my state did not have a qualified surgeon to take on the ensuing complications, leaving me fluttering from one ER on the weekend, then working five days, then bee-lining to another ER the following Friday. The health insurance from this sales job would cover the costs in another state with a capable surgeon willing to fix me, but not until I had the money to pay. And so I had to endure three months of ring-around-the-ER-posey. This game I was forced to play left me with lasting financial debt that I will never be able to repay - yet another regret. One major regret - having experimental bottom surgery - led to a cascade of others. For me, gender transition was and continues to be dangerous, causing massive and recurring health issues. It was not successful and cured nothing. It gave me PTSD. My left arm, from which the skin was taken to create a faux phallus, has essentially left me disabled. My right arm - my good arm - recently was diagnosed with hairline fractures because I stopped taking testosterone a little while ago. I basically now have brittle bones decades too soon. I have been let go from good-paying jobs because of my activism. Over five years ago, I began a fight to stop childhood medical transition. I started by helping write the first bill that was heard in North Dakota and have not relented, obsessed with saving children from my disastrous decision to transition medically rapidly, becoming one of the leading worldwide voices to stop childhood medical transition. Yes, a transman is leading the fight, and that in itself should cause you pause. I have dedicated my life to stopping my childhood medical transition, and the obligation has weighed heavy on my own family. I’m crippled with debt. I’m trans and I cannot detransition, even though I’d like to. The process has gone too far - there is no turning back. And so all I can do is try to be as resilient as Job, even though I understand no better. The woman in the coffee shop is still there, smiling at me, oblivious to the regrets that flash through my mind. "Oh my, Scott, how are you? We saw you in the documentary and were so thankful to see you alive; we have been worried about you for years. How are you now? Scott, what powerful testimony you have and are giving to so many." The smiling wife had been a customer before my appointment with the surgeon who was going to fix my original botched phalloplasty. I had done it! I finally had my insurance activated: success. But the insistent infections had taken their toll on my health, both physically and emotionally. A month prior, a doctor from my ER hopping insisted I get a PIC line put in my arm, the same tube they insert for cancer patients to receive IV their biweekly treatment. This tube traveled up my arm and ended right at the entrance of my heart, remaining for over 30 days. Each day, I would wake up, go to the hospital and receive IV antibiotics before I headed off to sell windows in people's homes. This woman wasn’t just a customer - she was my last customer. I distinctly recall the pain I had felt as an infection pulled on my bladder like daggers, but that quickly faded as I was embraced by the love and warmth emanating from the depths of this family's home. I was giving my presentation, saying "Here is the latch that opens the windows," when she interrupted me: "Scott, sweetie, you have blood running down your legs.” The kindness and genuine concern I felt from this couple, despite being strangers at the time, created a sense of comfort I will never forget. Their rare empathy hit a nerve within me, and I could not stop the tears I knew were coming. Once they started to flow, they didn't stop. I could not catch my breath, hyperventilating into the embrace of this woman and her husband. It was in his strong grasp I lost the ability to stand, yet I stayed upright because he held me along with his wife as his mammoth arms encircled us both. It was this nurturing man who began to comfort me in a whisper, "Shhh, it's ok, Scott, it's gonna be ok, you're ok, let it out." He reminded me of my father, who’d passed away a decade prior. Even though we were the same age, I felt from him a fatherly love I clearly must have needed. I was so grateful. Now here she was, years later, as I continued to try to navigate the complexity of emotion that characterizes regret, neither black nor white, positive nor negative, burden nor lesson, but all of these things, fueling internal growth whether I liked it or not. It is the degree of the negative that fuels the intensity of our regret; the harsher the adverse implications, the deeper the regret seeps into our consciousness. So yes, my regret is possibly as deep as it gets. I looked up at the expectant woman to give her my answer. “How am I? I’m still alive. And I live for my three kids.” When I was at my lowest, I thought about giving up entirely. But my kids’ faces came before and I made a promise: to live and to tell others about what happened to me. I’m far from perfect, as a person and as a parent. But I try. I try to help others so they don’t have the regrets that I have. Because of my regret and trying to make amends, my kids have had to grow up faster and better. But they are thriving, and that is everything. The woman smiled then and wished me well. I go back to looking at the want-ads with the free wifi from the coffee shop. I’m still an agnostic, but I’m also better off than Job. As a transgender man, I made the decision to undergo a medical transition, a choice which has brought about unintended consequences for my children. While I now recognize the detriment this decision has had on their well-being, there is an internal struggle I face in reconciling the need to raise awareness and understanding within society. On one hand, I am grateful for the opportunity to educate others and save other people's children from similar struggles. However, this gratitude is juxtaposed with the pain I witness my own children enduring as a result of my decision. It is a constant battle between acknowledging the selfishness underlying my initial choice and the desire to make a positive impact on society. Each day, I find myself grappling with regrets and questioning if this internal conflict will ever find resolution or if peace will ever be attained. The sheer magnitude of emotions I experience is overwhelming, and I am uncertain about how best to navigate through. Nonetheless, I am committed to understanding and addressing the consequences of my actions on my children's lives. I’ve endured the worst kind of suffering and the worst kind of regret. But I’m still here, and I’ll see my children grow up and for this I am forever grateful. Corinna Cohn is a writer, podcaster, and activist from Indiana. Corinna was diagnosed with gender identity disorder at age 15 and underwent surgical transition at age 19. In 2019, Corinna became involved in patient advocacy, and in 2022 began organizing to support legislation that regulates gender medicalization of minors. Corinna Cohn Regret or Survival I recently made a bad joke at a friend’s expense and instead of it coming off as teasing humor, it struck like a hammer. I was trying to be playful, but instead I caused hurt. Now, the memory keeps rising unbidden and it makes my cheeks flush with mortification. However, more profound regrets often stem from pivotal life choices, not just embarrassing moments. Regret is harder to understand when it’s been tightly wound around deeper and more difficult life experiences, especially related to choices we make during our formative years. As teenagers we are subjected to all types of novel and exciting ideas. We explore them, we play with them, and we try them on like outfits. Some of these ideas outrage our parents, and that makes them even more appealing. Throughout adolescence we have a belief that we’re the captains of our ships. It’s difficult for us to notice how impressionable we are and how we are moved to emulate our peers. We reject accusations that we’re conforming to a group or being influenced by peer pressure. In truth, even as adults we’re not immune from adapting views and attitudes from our friends and associates. We humans are social creatures; it’s in our nature. Looking backwards, the choices we’ve made during this stage of our life seem surreal. Our accumulated experience and wisdom can leave us akin to strangers to our younger selves. We are bereft of explanations when called to account for our decisions. It can be difficult to summon a sense of regret for events from which you’ve been alienated, even if you played a critical, causal role. Regret requires a sense of agency and participation. If you’re a victim of a disaster you will suffer agony, but if you caused the disaster you’ll know regret. If I could change my past, would I? Perhaps I would, but I’m not sure that it would be possible. I’d still be in a broken family home with a distant father and a co-dependent mother. I’d still be socially isolated from my peers, understanding masculinity like an outsider taking notes. I’d still be searching for affirmation and community on the early Internet, vulnerable to the influences of adults who ought to have known better. What could I practically change? Was I ever aware of a juncture that could have avoided an inevitable outcome? Did I ever make a choice, or was I swept along with the flood, paddling to keep my head above turbulent waters? It’s a blur. Those of us who underwent gender transition during adolescence may not reach for the word “regret” to describe our feelings and experiences, yet no single alternative stands out, but the one I prefer is this: survival. Rather than obsessing over things we can no longer change (even if we could), instead we should think about how we’ll endure the burden of our history. Regret cannot be resolved by rumination. We can only accept the terms of our present reality and make deliberate choices going forward. . Prisha Mosley speaks out publicly about the harm she has suffered through medical transion. She was young and very vulnerable when doctors and the trans community convinced her that medical transition was the solution to all of her problems. It wasn't! Now Prisha testifies across the country sharing the TRUTH about what happened to her, speaking candidly about the physical damage she still suffers from. Prisha shares her thoughts on her YouTube Channel (Prisha Mosley) and on X (@detransaqua) to WARN OTHERS through her first hand experience. Prisha has made a commitment to doing her part to stop child medical transition and the indoctrination of children and vulnerable adults. Prisha Mosley Prisha's Story "My name is Prisha Mosley. As a vulnerable child, I was convinced that I had only two options: transition or die. I was lied to about the nature and root of my distress. Instead of investigative or trauma based therapy, I was convinced that my puberty was a disease and that all of my problems were caused by being born in the wrong body. My doctors lied to me when they told me I could change sex. They lied about the results and outcome of gender transition. They lied about and obstructed facts about the dangers of GAC. I will live with lifelong medical regret because of the vulnerability and naivety of my youth and doctors' choices to exploit that. Regret is real."

  • Marcus Harris

    < Back Marcus Harris Account Director This is placeholder text. To change this content, double-click on the element and click Change Content. Want to view and manage all your collections? Click on the Content Manager button in the Add panel on the left. Here, you can make changes to your content, add new fields, create dynamic pages and more. Your collection is already set up for you with fields and content. Add your own content or import it from a CSV file. Add fields for any type of content you want to display, such as rich text, images, and videos. Be sure to click Sync after making changes in a collection, so visitors can see your newest content on your live site. info@mysite.com 123-456-7890

  • TReVoices - SCREAMING In The Media

    < Back OPPOSING OPINIONS AROUND PEDIATRIC MEDICAL TRANSITION AND GENDER IDEOLOGY By, Staff Writer UK NEWS This post will contain several examples of varying opinions about pediatric medical transition and gender activism. Trans Opposition to Pediatric Medical Transition and Gender Activism Not all trans people believe in pediatric medical transition as the medical side effects can be intense, and surgeries and hormones have risks. Scott Newgent, an FtM trans person, has circulated a petition, “Adult Transgender & Non-Transgender People Against Medically Transitioning Children opposing medical treatment on minors.” Scott has suffered serious damage due to phalloplasty surgery, a dangerous operation with high rates of complications: Well, we are the marginalized group, along with the support of Non-Transgender adults, and we are telling you that medically transitioning children is wrong. In remaining quiet, we have cut a safe corner out for ourselves to live peacefully, but with the massive influx of children transitioning, we can in good conscience, stay silent no longer. Together, arm in arm, we come together from the LGBT community, the straight community, the conservative community, the liberal community, the Christian community, the Jewish community, and many more to save Transgender identifying children. A trans person in Canada is calling for an Inquiry into the rising numbers of children being treated for gender dysphoria, many of whom are in the foster care system. We are adding an older article that highlights the reality that there are disagreements, even among trans people, as to how gender non-conforming people should exist in society. The article, “Pakistan's traditional third gender isn't happy with the trans movement,” is about the conflict between tradition “third gender” culture and modern trans activism: For centuries, South Asia has had its own Khawaja Sira or third gender culture. The community, identifying as neither male nor female, are believed by many to be "God’s chosen people," with special powers to bless and curse anyone they choose. The acceptance of Khawaja Sira people in Pakistan has been held up internationally as a symbol of tolerance, established long before Europe and America had even the slightest semblance of a transgender rights movement. But the acceptance of people defining their own gender in Pakistan is much more complicated. The term transgender refers to someone whose gender identify differs from their birth sex. This notion is yet to take root in Pakistan and the transgender rights movement is only beginning to assert itself formally. Now, some third gender people in Pakistan say the modern transgender identity is threatening their ancient third gender culture. A “third gender” traditionalist comments on an MtF who uses female pronouns and is currently a supermodel: Bindiya Rana is the grand matriarch of the third gender community in Karachi. She doesn’t prescribe to the transgender identity. She is a Khawaja Sira, so revered that she is a guru (teacher) to more than 50 chelahs or apprentices. This relationship has a parental element and is a cornerstone of Khawaja Sira culture. Each chelah pledges allegiance to their guru, as they did to their guru before them. These family trees provide acceptance, social support and financial backing. Most chelahs give a percentage of their income to their gurus. It’s a lifetime commitment that allows the establishment of families that often replaces biological lineage. But those who identify as transgender, like Choudary, don’t subscribe to the guru-chelah system. As a result, Rana and her chelahs view the transgender identity as alien and even immoral. “If you don’t have a guru, we don’t recognize you. These people who say they are transgender; that concept is just wrong," says one of Rana's chelahs. "They can never be women. They cannot give birth. Even if they change their bodies they can’t change who they are. We are not women. We are what Allah has made.” The Pakistani example highlights that there is more acceptance of trans than the concept of homosexuality in the Muslim world where homosexuality is punishable by death. Trans Identity as a form of Self-Harm GHQ is adding an older article from the New Statesmen, which discusses how female body hatred around gender dysphoria is being normalized despite the fact that doing things like breast binding is physically damaging: And yet, look again at that list of side effects: breathing difficulties, skeletal problems, fainting, inability to participate fully in exercise. The female adolescents wearing binders have reproduced all the problems of tight-lacing corsets, this time in the service of restrictive anti-femininity rather than restrictive femininity. So is issuing guidance to reduce the harms of binder-wearing in schools an act of care for transgender children, or an abdication of it? Is the role of adults in authority – whether parental, educational or medical – to validate everything that comes under the rubric of transition, regardless of long-term consequences, or could another approach be better? LGB Conflicts with Gender Politics Andrew Sullivan made a brief reference to gender identity politics in a discussion about the sweep by the conservative Tories in Britan in a recent election. We cover some similar opposing viewpoints that are a reaction to some of the cultural influences of postmodern queer theory. It is clearer and clearer to me that the wholesale adoption of critical race, gender, and queer theory on the left makes normal people wonder what on earth they’re talking about and which dictionary they are using. A paper called Disaffirming Gender: Somatic Incongruence as a Co-function of Ideological Congruity covers the conflicting interests that can exist between concepts of sexual orientation and gender identity: The activist conjunction of sexual orientation and gender identity is questioned by demonstrating how the concerns of the transgender movement run contrary to an agenda of liberation from gender ideology. The confused vocabulary of trans discourse articulated in the language of somatic incongruence (so-called gender dysphoria) is exposed, using an analysis of the concept of somatic incongruence and the various interventions through which bodies are apparently restored to ideological congruence constructed upon, inter alia, gender, race, and age. The paper rejects transgender medical treatment and surgery as nothing but the most brutal affirmation of gender stereotypes and, in conclusion, calls for a radical and total disaffirming of gender, analogous to the termination of racial classification and segregation. Below are several articles about the formation of the LGB Alliance in the UK. The organization was formed to advocate for LGB interests away from the demands of trans activism, which include transitioning young children and MtFs taking positions on girls’ sports teams. This article covers the views of a former member of Stonewall UK who supports the breakaway LGB organization: Fanshawe believes that the Stonewall of today is undermining the rights of lesbians and putting women and girls at risk by “unthinkingly” merging the rights of lesbians and gays with those of trans people through its ‘acceptance without exception’ dogma as it lobbies for transgender people to be able to legally self-identify as the gender they feel they are without having to provide evidence that they have lived in that gender for two years or by having gender dysphoria diagnosed. LGBAlliance is going so far as to challenge Stonewall UK backed initiatives: The LGB Alliance is of the view that Stonewall’s advice misrepresents the Equality Act, which recognizes sex as a protected characteristic. By replacing biological sex with gender identity, the LGB Alliance argues, Stonewall contravene legislation designed to uphold women’s rights. They describe this position as ‘Stonewall Law’ and fully intend to fight it. There are always accusations of bigotry in LGBT discourse when other groups wish to advocate without adding trans interests. This is from Quillette. Are gay people allowed to meet and organise in defense of their interests? A hard yes, you might have thought. But some apparently disagree. Witness the response to the London-based LGB Alliance, a newly created British group that asserts “the rights of lesbian, gay and bisexual people to define themselves as same-sex-attracted.” The group’s creation has sparked vitriol, not from the traditionalist Christians or social conservatives who might have opposed such groups in the 1980s or 1990s, but from the self-described progressive left. There is an article in the Spectator that covers trans activist approaches to promoting trans acceptance in women’s spaces like sports and prisons and pediatric medical transition. The information comes from a report from a British law firm: The report is called ‘Only adults? Good practices in legal gender recognition for youth’. Its purpose is to help trans groups in several countries bring about changes in the law to allow children to legally change their gender, without adult approval and without needing the approval of any authorities. ‘We hope this report will be a powerful tool for activists and NGOs working to advance the rights of trans youth across Europe and beyond,’ says the foreword. Below are some relevant quotes from the article about strategy: ‘While cultural and political factors play a key role in the approach to be taken, there are certain techniques that emerge as being effective in progressing trans rights in the “good practice” countries’… ‘In many of the NGO advocacy campaigns that we studied, there were clear benefits where NGOs managed to get ahead of the government and publish progressive legislative proposal before the government had time to develop their own. NGOs need to intervene early in the legislative process and ideally before it has even started. This will give them far greater ability to shape the government agenda and the ultimate proposal than if they intervene after the government has already started to develop its own proposals’… ‘In Ireland, Denmark and Norway, changes to the law on legal gender recognition were put through at the same time as other more popular reforms such as marriage equality legislation. This provided a veil of protection, particularly in Ireland, where marriage equality was strongly supported, but gender identity remained a more difficult issue to win public support for.’ ‘Another technique which has been used to great effect is the limitation of press coverage and exposure. In certain countries, like the UK, information on legal gender recognition reforms has been misinterpreted in the mainstream media, and opposition has arisen as a result. ….Against this background, many believe that public campaigning has been detrimental to progress, as much of the general public is not well informed about trans issues, and therefore misinterpretation can arise. In Ireland, activists have directly lobbied individual politicians and tried to keep press coverage to a minimum in order to avoid this issue.’ (Emphasis added). The Times of London posted another article about trans activist money in politics: A pharmaceutical firm that markets drugs used in gender-identity clinics to delay puberty has given £100,000 to the Liberal Democrats. Jo Swinson’s party has already upset feminists, who worry that the “extreme trans-ideological” policies in its manifesto will put vulnerable women at risk. Denying Trans People Emotional & Sexual Access is “Transphobia” There is an ongoing narrative that people should be emotionally and sexually available to trans people based on the trans person’s gender identity, or that person is a bigot or a transphobic. This is from a recent article in Slate: Stoya: I’m having difficulty putting myself in to the shoes of a person who is so off put by genital configuration. Rich: Look, I’m way more into dick. Maybe I need to work on that, but it feels OK to like what I like. I don’t fantasize about vulvas; I do dicks. It’s plausible that someone has a type formed by a bunch of factors that are specific and don’t make him a bad person. But it’s also not just possible but observable and prevalent to have “preferences” that dog-whistle bigotry. I think these things require a lot of self-interrogation. GHQ reviews the conflicts this is causing here and here. Comments from Jesse Singal: @jessesingal The Advocate also published an article arguing it’s transphobic not to date trans people as some trans people are trying to make this concept mainstream: The question that gets danced around, however, is: “Are all these numbers indicative of transphobia?” The answer, I believe, is clearly yes. The Spectator commented on the strained arguments in the Advocate article: Those who deny the existence of biological sex and insist a person can change sex through self-declaration have made a number of grave mistakes — some of which harm their own community. The promise of ‘passing’ — a term that refers to trans-identified people who are perceived to be the opposite sex, rather than simply a male attempting to dress ‘like a woman’ or vice versa — is in fact quite cruel. Most trans-identified people won’t ‘pass’ in public; but even if they manage to appear as the sex they wish to be on a day to day basis, all sorts of subtle cues betray them when it comes to attracting their desired partner. Trans Activism Trans activists have reacted angrily to a book promoting body positivity in children called My Body is Me! due to the fact it promotes body acceptance and was cosponsored by Transgendertrend, a group that questions the ethics of pediatric transition: My Body is Me is an upbeat, rhyming picture book, aimed for 3-6 year olds, written by Rachel Rooney and illustrated by Jessica Ahlberg in consultation with TransgenderTrend. It introduces children to the workings of the human body, and celebrates similarities and differences while challenging sex stereotypes. It also aims to promote a positive self-image and foster self-care skills. The text is inclusive for children with physical or sensory disabilities. In an example of extremist gender activism, Debbie Hayton (who is on the GHQ Board) is trans and is being targetting for not believing it is possible to change your biological sex: A transgender woman has been accused of transphobia for wearing a T-shirt saying she is really still a man. Debbie Hayton, 51, a physics teacher in the Midlands, who transitioned from male to female in 2012, is facing expulsion from the LGBT committee of the Trades Union Congress (TUC) for the slogan: “Trans women are men. Get over it!” Jake Pyne is an FtM activist who is part of GDAWorkinggroup.com. This website was set up with almost the same name as a group of health professionals (GDworkinggroup) who advocate a more cautious approach in an apparent attempt to challenge them. The site members consist of the people at the forefront of trans activism and the affirmative model, such as Diane Ehrensaft and Johanna Olson-Kennedy. Jake Pyne is also allegedly responsible for spreading a false allegation against Dr. Ken Zucker in order to get him fired for his more conservative approach to medically transitioning minors. Below is a screencap of Pyne laughing at a joke about murdering a reporter, which is common behavior over the internet: Multiple trans voices take issue with pediatric medical transition and some of the more radical aspects of trans activism. Changing Laws and Policies to Allow Pediatric Medical Transition Without Parental Consent The below case is an example of the new normal. Parents will lose the ability to have their children wait until they are adults to alter their body medically. This case is in Europe, but the same activist push exists in all Western countries: By the parents' admission, they warned “Nea” that sex change is a complex and traumatising procedure, and that some of its effects are irreversible. They suggested waiting until the school year's end, going back to Finland, undergoing a thorough medical examination, and learning more about the consequences of getting a sex change. However, “Nea”, with the help of a representative from a local trans organisation, went to the police and reported her parents for opposing her gender reassignment procedures. The authorities in the unnamed EU country supported the underage girl. The Conservative think tank site Public Discourse reviews some conflicts of interest in allowing trans-identified students in girls bathrooms: The case against compelled affirmation policies needs to be more explicitly and vividly sexualized. The argument against these policies must be rooted in the civil liberties of objecting students and the right not be forced to be the object of another’s sexual gaze. Opening intimate facilities to anyone of the opposite sex imposes psycho-sexual trauma on countless non-consenting youths, and constitutes a form of sexual exploitation. The case: Consider the experience of some northern Illinois high-school girls, as one federal court recently described it. In Students and Parents for Privacy v. High School District 211, Judge Jorge Alonso wrote that several of them were “startled, shocked, embarrassed, and frightened by the presence of a male in the girls’ restroom,” most especially when “female student A” was “exposed to this male’s penis.” No wonder: he also found that these students “are at continual risk of encountering (and sometimes do encounter), without their consent, members of the opposite sex while disrobing, showering, urinating, defecating and while changing tampons and feminine napkins.” The naked guy was no streaker or everyday pervert. He was a student. The school did nothing to discipline him. In fact, the school authorities had sent him there under what they unapologetically called a “compelled affirmation” policy governing transgendered students’ access to intimate school facilities. Judge Alonso dismissed all complaints about the policy that were based on rights protected by the Constitution, including the free exercise of religion, students’ right of bodily privacy, and parents’ right to direct the education of their children. He did, however, permit statutory claims for sexual harassment and violation of the Illinois Religious Freedom Restoration Act to go forward, possibly to trial. The legal expert wants these cases to elicit sexually in the minds of the public: I think that the case against compelled affirmation policies needs to be more explicitly and vividly sexualized. By that I mean that the argument against these policies must be rooted in the civil liberties of objecting students, as they pertain to the morality of acts which cause sexual arousal; which instigate impure thoughts; and which threaten both the healthy psycho-sexual development of young people and—most importantly in our cultural moment—the right not to be forced to be the object of another’s sexual gaze—the occasion for the arousal of another person. This improvement synthesizes the prevailing privacy contentions (which, again, are sound so far as they go); extends them; and focuses the argument on something that even judges who have been mesmerized by transgender-affirming propaganda might find hard to sanction: opening intimate facilities to anyone of the opposite sex (that is, anyone bearing the sexually provocative body parts of the opposite sex) imposes psycho-sexual trauma on countless unconsenting youths, and constitutes a form of sexual exploitation. Most MtFs who transition at young ages are not sexually attracted to females. They are very effeminate homosexual males. However, most MtFs are autogynephilc males, are sexually attracted to women, and appear to be coming out at younger ages. The school system in these cases would be putting heterosexual males in with teenage girls in situations that involve nudity. Gender ideology, something some LGBT people strongly disagree with, is taught to children in schools in multiple countries in the world: For trans ideology to truly spread, it needs to become an inherent part of our core belief system. As natural as the sky being blue, and the earth being round, we must all have the truth of trans as a foundational element of our understanding about the world for it to thrive. Convincing adults is one thing, but to really make this wash, it’s children that need to taught the dogma of multiple gender identities and the ability of humans to swap their sex for its opposite. The purported goal behind teaching children that male and female are nothing more than feelings is compassion, empathy, and anti-bias. The work to bring children into the trans fold is pervasive and growing, and we’ve seen it in the US and Canada. In Sweden, the government is pouring money into an educational program for drag queens to read to children with disabilities. Meanwhile, in the UK, where trans advocates have a major head start, the BBC is airing educational programming to teach children that there are as many genders as stars in the sky. The article “Schools told all lessons for five-year-olds should include gay and trans themes” discusses the issue of when and how to teach children about gender identity and sexual orientation. South Carolina wants to ban underage medical treatment for trans-identified youth. There is a recorded video of a conservative father rebelling against gender ideology being taught to children in school. Miscellaneous Here is an account of a medical student who believes the sciences are embracing ideology over scientific facts regarding gender identity and biological sex. REFERENCES A Concerned Medical Student Speaks Out. (2019, December 2019). Retrieved from https://www.kelseycoalition.org/pubs/A-Concerned-Medical-Student-Speaks-Out?fbclid=IwAR2DbQujxTiw29Pbd_mL_mHUq_beuD9sOoii-RjAZpOPFHGzH2v3fZOaPj4 Azhar, M. (2017, July 29). Pakistan's traditional third gender isn't happy with the trans movement. PRI. Retrieved from https://www.pri.org/stories/2017-07-29/pakistans-traditional-third-gender-isnt-happy-trans-movement Bradley, G. (2019, December 1). Compelled Sexual Affirmation in the School Bathroom. Public Discourse. Retrieved from https://www.thepublicdiscourse.com/2019/12/58498/ Ditum, S. (2016, October 25). How society is failing transgender children. New Statesman. Retrieved from https://www.newstatesman.com/politics/feminism/2016/10/how-society-failing-transgender-childrenGriffiths, S., Walsh, J. (2019, December 1). Schools told all lessons for five-year-olds should include gay and trans themes. Retrieved from https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/7d300e42-13ad-11ea-b97d-3a49c0ea7ce7?fbclid=IwAR0C9LRDIB3bzIcj-Tu-H2ooFxf7B8AtRsDP8ooB49WtNZNtLG7zTcDjsf0 Emmons, L. (2019, November 22). Teachers are indoctrinating our children in radical trans ideology. The Post Millenial. Retrieved from https://www.thepostmillennial.com/teachers-are-indoctrinating-our-children-in-radical-trans-ideology/ Hellen, N., Wheeler, C. (2019, December 8). Puberty-blocker drug firm donated cash to Lib Dems. The Times[London]. Retrieved from https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/puberty-blocker-drug-firm-donated-cash-to-lib-dems-cf3x77nh3 Hellen, N. (2019, December 22). Trans woman Debbie Hayton faces ban for transphobia. The Times[London]. Retrieved from https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/trans-woman-debbie-hayton-faces-ban-for-transphobia-96tfkl5gc?fbclid=IwAR0glDgonjBJMJwv0-iYMY468WrPD72KSAps3-n46Pz4I2uUrC5NbS4PMlY Heuchan, C. (2019, November 7). LGB Alliance asks Human Rights Watchdog to Investigate ‘Stonewall Law.’ After Ellen. Retrieved from https://www.afterellen.com/general-news/573118-lgb-alliance-asks-human-rights-watchdog-to-investigate-stonewall-law Jenn Smith Calls for Provincial&National Inquiries into mass gender transitioning of Vulnerable kids. (2019, October 19). Retrieved from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aPBfHgxWGwE Joyce, H. (2019, November 4). Meet the Gay Activists Who’ve Had Enough of Britain’s Ultra-Woke Homophobes. Quillette. Retrieved from https://quillette.com/2019/11/04/meet-the-gay-activists-whove-had-enough-of-britains-ultra-woke-homophobes/ Kiirkup, J. (2019, December 2). The document that reveals the remarkable tactics of trans lobbyists. The Spectator. Retrieved from https://blogs.spectator.co.uk/2019/12/the-document-that-reveals-the-remarkable-tactics-of-trans-lobbyists/ Losing a Daughter, Not Gaining a Son: Finnish Parents Who Opposed Teen's Sex Change Lose Custody. (2019, December 12). Sputnik News. Retrieved from https://sputniknews.com/society/201912121077550078-losing-a-daughter-not-gaining-a-son-finnish-parents-who-opposed-teens-sex-change-lose-custody/ Murphy, M. (2019, December 19). Are you heterosexual? Or simply transphobic? The Spectator. Retrieved from https://spectator.us/heterosexual-simply-transphobic/?fbclid=IwAR27cIwt6-CxA0mabnlg4iX1kfDrkeX8SNbLcZ-XlgKWxbOId4bKrHaIGO0# North, A. (2019, November 25). South Carolina wants to ban lifesaving medical treatments for trans kids. Vox. Retrieved from https://www.vox.com/2019/11/22/20977721/south-carolina-trans-transgender-youth-gender-reassignment Olver, T. (2019). Disaffirming Gender: Somatic Incongruence as a Co-function of Ideological Congruity. The Psychoanalytic Review 106(1),1-28. DOI: 10.1521/prev.2019.106.1.1 Phalloplasty gone wrong. (2019, September 4). Retrieved from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FAJSILE_wGc Rhodes, M. (2019, November 4). Co-founder of Stonewall calls for calm. Holyrood. Retrieved from https://www.holyrood.com/inside-politics/view,cofounder-of-stonewall-calls-for-calm_14648.htm Rooney, R., Ahlberg, J. (2019). My Body is Me!. Published by Transgendertrend. Singal, J. (2017, February 7). How the Fight Over Transgender Kids Got a Leading Sex Researcher Fired. The Cut. Retrieved from https://www.thecut.com/2016/02/fight-over-trans-kids-got-a-researcher-fired.html Stoya, R. Juzwiak. (2019, November 7). “I Hope This Doesn’t Make Me a Terrible Person." Slate. Retrieved from https://slate.com/human-interest/2019/11/ask-trans-women-about-their-genitals-while-dating.html Sullivan, A. (2019, December 13). Boris Johnson Is Showing Western Politicians How to Win. New York Magazine. Retrieved from http://nymag.com/intelligencer/2019/12/andrew-sullivan-boris-johnsons-winning-formula.html Tannehill, B. (2019, December 14). Is Refusing to Date Trans People Transphobic? The Advocate. Retrieved from https://www.advocate.com/commentary/2019/12/14/refusing-date-trans-people-transphobic?fbclid=IwAR3sftFezusxMKMsL5i0tDzKTQKx_nx2-s7O0y6IWFmZ3jkURrp3a7DUMjU Original Link

  • Claudia McleanTReVoices.org - A Trans Activist Making Waves With Reason An Logic.Trans Woman

    Get to know trans people, the real trans living day to day, what they believe, and how they feel. You will find that most older trans people believe what is happening to kids, and transgender ideology is hurtful. The media leaders you currently see do not represent most trans people. Reality Is Not Bigotry < Back Trans Woman Claudia Mclean TReVoices.org - A Trans Activist Making Waves With Reason An Logic. Follow Claudia on: Twitter I started out singing in Glasgow, then Europe, coming back to sing in London, even the Palladium. Activism followed. ‘03~’07 GMC Trial. Disabled but still here. Claudia is a beautiful Irish soul, a singer, full of grace and charm. Claudia was the first trans to come out publicly in a BBC News story; in 2007, she regretted the decision to transition medically. I can say with understanding that this was one hell of an accomplishment. It's terrifying coming out and stating, 'Yeah, that was stupid; I should have never transitioned." But Claudia did and paved the way for more trans to stand up and say the same thing. Claudia has become a mentor to me, and I try and honour her every day, letting her know that her strength didn't go unnoticed. Claudia is a twin to my experience medically transitioning; we both transitioned due to homophobia. Pushed by our partners, we both suffer from reoccurring bacterial infections due to our bottom surgeries and suffer daily living each day, knowing that the following infection might be the one that takes our life. It's a real fear and something people need to know. Claudia and I are not the anomalies; unfortunately, we are normality with trans who undergo bottom surgeries. Claudia is also unable to walk and wheelchair-bound due to bone deterioration and prolonged use of synthetic estrogen. Claudia is also unable to have sexual relations and has had to forgo this bonding experience due to a failed bottom surgery. I know right...Wait What? Prolonged use of estrogen on male bodies cause bone deterioration, and it's common and trans bottom surgery risks the ability to have sex and orgasm. Yes, it is, now you SCREAM! "I should never have had sex-change surgery," Claudia MacLean, a transsexual woman, told the audience at a recent debate organized by the BBC Radio 4 programme Hecklers and the Royal Society of Medicine in London. "As a result of the surgery, I am incapable of sex, and I have lived a life apart." TReVoices Contributions & Latest Work: A Transwoman Writes A Letter To Politicians About Transwomen In Sport s

  • TReVoices - SCREAMING In The Media

    < Back ​Twitter Bans Transman For Telling The Horrific Truth By, Magnus McCoy & Scott Newgent US This is what happens when you go against the liberal narrative, even when you are part of a group they put on a pedestal. Scott Newgent was originally Kelly King, a woman who underwent numerous surgeries to look like a man. But unlike other trans, Newgent has been warning others not to make the change. Newgent took to Twitter to warn others and was banned for it. You'd think that Newgent would be ok on the liberal platform but apparently, they don't want people to hear a voice of reason. Newgent explained the horrors associated with the sex-change surgeries and other treatments that Liberals don't want the public to know about. "During my own transition, I had seven surgeries. I also had a massive pulmonary embolism, a helicopter life-flight ride, an emergency ambulance ride, a stress-induced heart attack, sepsis, a 17-month recurring infection due to using the wrong skin during a (failed) phalloplasty, 16 rounds of antibiotics, three weeks of daily IV antibiotics, the loss of all my hair, (only partially successful) arm reconstructive surgery, permanent lung and heart damage, a cut bladder, insomnia-induced hallucinations—oh and frequent loss of consciousness due to pain from the hair on the inside of my urethra. All this led to a form of PTSD that made me a prisoner in my apartment for a year. Between me and my insurance company, medical expenses exceeded $900,000. During these 17 months of agony, I couldn’t get a urologist to help me. They didn’t feel comfortable taking me on as a patient—since the phalloplasty, like much of the transition process, is experimental. “Could you go back to the original surgeon?” they suggested. Several lawyers suggested I had a slam-dunk medical malpractice case—until they realized that trans health doesn’t really have a justiciable baseline. As a result, treatment often is subpar, as I have experienced first-hand. Lupron, the hormone blocker some doctors seem intent on giving to kids like Tylenol, isn’t even FDA-approved to treat children with gender dysphoria. (In 2001, the manufacturer pled guilty to fraudulent sales practices with regard to its marketing as a prostate cancer drug.) We don’t yet know its long-term effects off-label, despite the fact parents have been assured that its effects are safe and even reversible. Here is what we do know: The long-term use of synthetic hormone therapy shortens lives. Specifically, these medications are associated with an increased risk of heart attacks, pulmonary embolisms, bone damage, liver and kidney failure, mental-health complications, and more. Almost a quarter of hormone-therapy patients on high-dose anabolic steroids (such as the testosterone taken by female-to-male transitioners) exhibit major mood-syndrome symptoms. Between three and 12 percent go on to develop symptoms of psychosis. Children who claim to be trans typically are receiving such drugs at a pivotal time in the development of brains and bones. They’ve become a generation of guinea pigs, to answer such questions as: What will happen to a biological boy who takes sex hormones associated with the opposite sex (or vice versa), and grows up without the benefit of natural puberty? What happens to a male body on estrogen over the long term? No one knows." Newgent goes on to say that kids who claim they are going to kill themselves if they don't get the treatment, need psychological help, and parents shouldn't give in to their wants. Newgent went through the whole procedure and would be an expert on the issue. But Liberals for some reason think it is hateful that a woman, who did a full sex change, should warn others against it... Original Link

  • TReVoices - SCREAMING In The Media

    < Back Wild West Of Transgender Surgery - It's All Experimental - Yee Haw! By, Scott Newgent US Deciding to get a Phalloplasty is a personal journey. The surgery itself is a hot button in the transgender community, and, I believe it will continue to be for quite some time. I'm not a Doctor just a patient, so these explanations, experiences as well as opinions will be with my limited knowledge from a clinical perspective. Some incidents are mine, some I have read in medical malpractices cases, and others are ones I listened to over coffee with friends. Excuse the explicit account, but I want to put the complexities and expectations into a realistic viewpoint, it would have benefited me when I started this pilgrimage. Lets start with a quick synopsis of the most popular FTM bottom surgeries and then finish with the ,"Flagship," the Phalloplasty. Metoidioplasty: This releases the clitoris: Like somehow It's being held down by forces unknown to us, quite comical because medically it just about covers how women have been treated since the beginning of time. Once the clitoris is released, the surgeon then wraps around the labia minora skin to create a little penis. A scrotoplasty can be designed to give an even more realistic atheistic, and a urethra lengthening can be added to provide the patient with the ability to pee while standing. The Metoidioplasty was developed in the '70s and is a far less evasive surgery than the Phalloplasty. You get a realistic-looking little penis and can stand to pee. But, let's face it penetration is most likely out of the question. With testosterone treatment, the trans man does grow a more extended and bigger clitoris, but having one grow big enough to penetrate is a rumor that I have not been able to clear up. I have had a couple of FTM patients tell me they can penetrate, but I always have questioned that in my mind. Pros: Cheaper $5,000-$20,000 depending on what you choose to do, and if you add on a urethra lengthening and a scrotum, less downtime, and fewer chances of complications. The surgery is not incredibly long, 2-5 hours, depending on what doctor or website you read. Cons: Just one, penetration…NOPE. Centurion: The Centurion was invented and performed by Dr. Peter Raphael in Dallas, Texas. I had my top surgery, and a couple of other things done by Dr. Raphael. This guy is an artist. He has an impressive background; his father was a surgeon and his mother a talented artist, and he kind of twists that into one in Plastic Surgery. If you walk by his office, sometimes you can catch him sculpting implants trying to figure out better ways to create the most realistic scrotum — great guy, sincere with helping people in the transgender community, careful and adept. Dr. Raphel is a little more costly but worth the investment. This procedure can also add urethra lengthening giving the patient the ability to pee and a scrotum. Pros: It's a Metoidioplasty on steroids, more prominent and more realistic. Cheaper than a Phalloplasty $8,000-$20,000 Cons: Again, sorry guys penetration is not really an option. Ok, so now let us get to the "Flagship," of female to male bottom surgery the……drum roll Please. Phalloplasty. If you research this bad boy online, you will think you hit the jackpot. Realistic penis, penetration, pee while standing an all-around winner winner chicken dinner. But things are not always what they seem to be, especially with marketing experts and the capricious powers of the internet, creating smoke and mirrors. Phalloplasty: In the 1940s Sir Harold Gilles was the first surgeon to take skin from another part of the body to create a penis, but the first Surgeons to try and tackle this colossal surgery didn't happen here in the USA until the 70s. With this surgery, the surgeon takes skin from two different sites on the body; one harvesting area is cut into deeper and, full recovery to the skin's initial appearance is never regained. The surgeon then creates a urethra lengthening procedure and takes the skin from the site where it is harvested and molds and stitches a penis. Once completed, the skin is re-attached and put back onto the body. Pros: Awwww, penetration, maybe? Cons: Wow. Well, first the surgery can take anywhere from 10-20 hours to complete the process you can have anywhere from 2-22 operations, depending on complications and complications are vast, numerous, and frequent. Since the skin is not able to become erect, the actual penis is long and cumbersome all the time. Recovery is brutal, not a, "Hey boss, I need a couple of weeks off to have a surgery." NOPE! This recovery is months and months if not years, depending on what type of complications you have. This is an expensive surgery $50,000 on the super low end up to hundreds of thousands of dollars. If your insurance does cover this surgery, make sure they will cover the additional operations to complete the surgery and all the complications that may arise. So, you still want to get a Phalloplasty; the idea of penetration is just something you have to have. Sure, I get it, and that's the reason I did it too, as well as my ex-wife wanting the evasive, "Penetration." I get it, the allurement is appealing, but the draw has the potential to change many things in your life that you need to be aware of. This Surgery guys is no joke. But, when I first was looking into Phalloplasty, I obsessively searched the internet, and the plethora of information that pops up is like Disneyland for the FTM. Oh, my God it's too good to be true like Cinderella married the FTM with a Huge Penis, and they lived happily ever after enjoying penetration after penetration. As you open different sites, a handful of surgeons become the most relevant and they look so esteemed with awards, dual residencies, and success after success. If fact, if you dive deep into investigations, you can find fictitious accolades and awards that boast the potential Surgeon's competencies. If you base your decision to have a Phalloplasty on what is on the internet, you are making an ignorant decision with lots of moving parts. Imagine yourself skipping down the yellow brick road just like Dorthy from the Wizard of Oz. Do you recall who was behind the curtain? Do you? Now imagine deciding something as drastic as a Phalloplasty with a couple of clicks of a mouse. It's dangerous and downright insane. Be sure your Surgeon behind the curtain doesn't resemble the all Powerful Oz from the wizard of Oz. If you research some of these doctors you will find medical malpractice cases, but you must do your homework, merely checking doctors state board license is not enough. Malpractice cases can be hidden by settling or leaving the state and starting a new. If you investigate, you will find that the decision to get a Phalloplasty obliterated quite a few people's lives. The complication rate is enormous. Prior patients have been shattered physically, spiritual, and left in financial ruin. Having a big penis that you can use to penetrate with is not a fair trade for having to wear a colostomy bag for years or even the rest of your life, not in my estimation. Again, I'm not revealing anything about my experience; this was something I read about in a malpractice case. First, let us take the skin that needs to be removed to create the penis. You have three choices, the forearm, the thigh, and the upper back. To be able to use the leg for harvesting the patient needs to have a specific body to fat ratio for the procedure to work, this skin also must have a certain elasticity. Depending on the age and body fat of the patient, this might or might not be an option. The benefit to the thigh is the harvesting sight on the leg can be covered; this part of your body is never going to look the same; you need to understand this. You will look like a burn victim; it's just where you will look like you got burned. The con is that it's not the best site for sensation, it's not the gravest but you could or could not be able to orgasm. I'm not bullshitting you; this is your life you need to understand this stuff. The second place for harvesting skin is from the upper back. Again, this area can be covered, but the sensation is less. You're, odds of orgasming goes down even further. Who wants to go through all this pain, money, and suffering to have a penis that doesn't allow you to orgasm? The last area is the forearm, and the pros to this area are the sensation great, the bad news is that your arm will never look or work the same. For some reason, this information is almost nonexistent when you search the internet. The Surgeons web sites quickly skim through this as if it's no big deal. You can google images though, and these are realistic, look at these don't ignore these, these pictures of what you will be putting your arm through. My surgeon downplayed using the forearm site to the point I allowed myself to feel silly for being troubled about questioning whether or not I should use the forearm. In fact, as I look back, my surgeon was the pivotal point in my entire decision to get the Phalloplasty. Sure, my wife wanted it, but if I knew what I know now, I would have never made the decision to have a Phalloplasty. My surgeon had this arrogance and gave me such little time, it pushed me into the belief that I should believe him, and because of that, I did. It reminds me of a cult where the followers start to question things, but they look around, and everyone else is so obedient and faithful that they figure it's just them. Little do they know in the background the leader is shuffling people and rumors around, so they don't eventually meet up and figure out the leader is full of shit. The authenticity, for me, is that my arm is handicapped for the rest of my life. It hurts to type on the computer, I can't play sports, and my hand remains swollen years after the surgery and it, well it hurts all the time. Not the pulsing pain that ravages you, the, "Damn my hand hurts and I'm having a hard time holding a fork to eat," type of pain. Pain that gives you a glimpse into what your body might feel like as a 100-year-old man, but just in your arm. It's depressing I can't lie. Another predicament is nerve damage; the surgeon cuts so deep that nerve endings are exposed, and they may never close for the rest of your life. For me, I must wear a brace because a graze on my forearm skin sends me through the roof with shock. Another delicacy is that the skin I was speaking about is not all the skin that needs harvesting. Another area is used to gather more skin, usually the thigh, but it's not as deep, so the scar is quite unnoticeable. But, wow, talk about a road rash gone wild, hurts, hurts and hurts some more. The good news with this harvest sight is that the pain concedes in six weeks. Donor site information seemed to be leaped over and lessened by the websites for the surgeons and the surgeons themselves when you have the consultations. I encourage you to google pictures of the parts of the body and how they harvest the skin. Look at those images with both eyes open. If you are speaking with a surgeon and he or she minimizes the harvesting of skin, I would be worried because this is not a walk in the park and this can leave you damaged in many ways if you choose the wrong decision for yourself. Another predicament is nerve damage; the surgeon cuts so deep that nerve endings are exposed, and they may never close for the rest of your life. For me, I must wear a brace because a graze on my forearm skin sends me through the roof with shock. Are you prepared for the daily and the never-ending question you will get if you leave your arm exposed, "What happened to your arm question?" You can come up with your own response. But, I like to say, "Oh, I used the skin to create a penis. It doesn't work right because I was born with a vagina. But, my wife wanted me to be able to penetrate her and pee standing up. She didn't want me to embarrass her if I was ever in a gym locker with any of her friends or family. One always has to look after their reputation. Don't you agree? Recovery from the harvest area on the forearm is years, and from my experience, you never get the full use of your arm again so, if you choose your arm to be prepared to look like a burn victim and be ready to have a disabled forearm for life. So, you want to pee standing up? Who wouldn't really? What a convenience to pee standing up and if I had the choice, I would choose to pee standing up too. But think about this to go from a female urethra to a male urethra is tough. The urethra has to lengthen and run through the skin that is being used to create a penis. Creating something in surgery is much harder than cutting something off. When you create, you create the opportunity for complications, and the Phalloplasty is generating a ton of different things at once in one surgery. The Phalloplasty complication rate ranges between 39% - 95%. The complications vary depending on the length of the desired penis and urethra length. My on the street poll for complication rates with Phalloplasty is 100%. 100% of the people I have talked to and read about have had complications. If you google surgeons that have the Phalloplasty in their wheelhouse you will be pleasantly surprised by websites bolstering 100% success rates, limited explanations of complications and risks. Do not be fooled. My inquisition question would be to ask them, "at what cost?" If I told you, "Hey bud, ride your bike 10 miles to the next town but, the probability you are going to get hit by a car and maimed for life is between 39%-95%. Now, you may have up to a 95% chance of getting hit but, if you hang in there and endure having surgery up to 22 times, we guarantee that 100% you are going to pee standing up. Are you ducking nuts man? The most frequent complication of Phalloplasty urethra lengthening is Fistulas. Aw, fistulas those little inconveniences, inconsiderate small holes that develop between where the vagina was and the new path up to the bottom of the penis. These tiny holes cause significant problems and pain, my God the pain can be horrendous and cause serious infections as well as a detectable stench of urine that drains out of the holes throughout the day. Fistulas cause pain, swelling, incontinence, and the embarrassment of smelling like an infant or 100-year-old-man that needs to have their diaper changed. The problem is the stench will be coming from you, and you will have to learn how to carry diapers so that you can change them several times a day. Take that as a confidence boost, and an excellent intimacy motivator between you are your lover. Sexual spontaneity will most likely be nonexistence. Good news though, but you might be able to pee standing up, but your fistula will dribble urine on the floor. Last fistulas have a high probability of not being successful in surgery. If you do need additional operations, be prepared to continue the process several times to get the issue resolved. But, in the end, you may still have to get rid of the urethra lengthening all together and re-route it back to the same place it was when you started. Peeing will again require that you sit down. Yup, that's right peeing sitting down. I hope you can still reach orgasm because that would be a real bummer! Infection, hell yes! Imagine having your skin ripped and burned from your body and placed on tables where a doctor creates a male organ and re-attached to your opened body carcass. The area where this exposed organ is being held together by stitches and gauze will be exposed to the outside elements for weeks and weeks. The wounds that need to heal are located inches from where you defecate. If you do develop a fistula urine will meet the wound as well. You're afraid of touching a bathroom doorknob? Hell, honey hold your breath, be strong and if it gets to you to bad break out the Xanax and don't think about it. Better yet, THINK ABOUT IT and the risks. For weeks you will have what is called a super pubic tube, this is a tube that comes out of the side of your body and travels inside you and inserted into the bladder to allow your Phalloplasty to heal. Some surgeons are ok with removing it after 4-6 weeks, and some won't remove it for months and months. It's uncomfortable but in my opinion the least evasive part of the surgery. Enjoy, no middle of the night bathroom breaks. Sepsis, ever heard of this medical delight? With the evasiveness of this surgery, which is mildly covering the bases of the severity. I like to gauge the bench of a Phalloplasty as inhuman and grotesque. In any case, the odds of getting an infection are high. If you add a sepsis infection, it can knock a patient back light years in recovery. Sepsis feels like you went ten rounds with Mike Tyson in the day and the spar ends with Bruce Lee jumping in the ring adding a roundhouse kick that catapults you back into the bed that is made up of steel nails. The least amount of movement feels like you are moving a house with your bare hands. Psychologically you feel defeated with the idea of having to change the channel on TV with a remote; it's bad guys. Sleeping is something you can forget about with the irritable leg symptoms. You can look forward to the gaze of insomnia as it sets in that leaves you feeling hopeless and lost. Surgeons? So what's with the surgeons that get into this field? Let's think about that. What part of society do we represent to people that are other than our friends and family? If we think about facts and not how we wished our culture was, what would that say to you? As transgender people, we are exposed to mockery, bigotry, loathing, judgment, and treated with the lowest form of virtue at times. How many times can you count where you have been out and overheard a joke about the transgender community only to watch the wine glasses click together with hilarity and approval. Hell, up until just recently we were the red-headed stepchild of the LGBT community. The last letter in the acronym of the least accepting society in the world. Even our kind, the LGBT community rejected us, derided us and only left a crack in the door for acceptance. It has only been since Jenner that have we have revered as even a species of the human race, and that was only 5 or 6 years ago. So, I ask you again, what surgeons go into this line of practice? Don't live in the fantasy Phalloplasty land. Let yourself be in denial about the kind of person you are married to, pick up the size 30 waist jeans and convincingly tell yourself these would fit you great. But, not with Phalloplasty and not with the surgeon you choose. The people in a part of society thought of less than is protected less. Why do you think serial killers with the longest careers target and kill indigents and prostitutes? Why? Because most people don't give a shit about them. I say most, because there are good people in the world, but far less that what you think. It’s human nature to act like Purana's feasting on a wounded fish in the water. That is why racism will never leave our world, it will always be there. Face it guys we are low hanging fruit to be mistreated, know that and understand you have to protect yourself because no one else will. That includes picking a competent Surgeon. You must ask yourself; Why would surgeons choose this type of surgery to perform? A general surgeon averages $220,000 salary a year. A specialized Cardiologist almost doubles that at $512,000. A standard appendectomy in the USA cost $21,000. A Phalloplasty with a scrotum, urethra lengthening and pump averages $85,000-$200,000 and insurance are covering it now. Think of the complication revenues from Phalloplasty alone. Hell, it might even be worth it to skimp here or there in surgery because who's going to care it's just a transgender person and the additional revenue could be a plus. I believe you can figure out the reason why this field is selected. A surgeon that is not good at anything else can jump into this area of practice and make a fortune, be sought after, have articles written about them, and have a narcissistic personality fed like royalty. To perform this surgery, you don't have to have any specialized education other than being a general surgeon. I can't find any medical guidelines or regulations or checks and balances. It's like the wild, wild west of surgery. In my opinion and experience with going through this Surgery, I believe Phalloplasty surgery should be illegal until regulations, and roads are in place to assure the surgeons that are administering the operations adhere to a strict set of guidelines. Since it is still legal, and I do believe there are incredible and genuine surgeons like Dr. Marci Bowars and Dr. Peter Rapheal, you need to ask your possible surgeons questions. If your potential surgeon is arrogant, doesn't allow you to see additional pictures of the past patients, or denies a request to speak to previous patient move on to another that will. Ask questions like, "How many medical malpractice cases have you had filed against you," not ones that you have paid off, so they are not on your record. How many have been filed? Check the medical boards on your potential Surgeons license, review the superior courts where your doctor is practicing. Look up medical malpractice cases on the surgeon you are working with; read them. Ask your potential surgeon if they are creating the male organ themselves or if they pay another surgeon to do it. In business, we call that subcontracting and the responsibility for issues that arise tend to be ping-ponged back and forth between the Surgeons. Who is going to be in the room during the operation, and who are the Doctors? Ask if a specialized arm Surgeon will be doing the work that is needed to harvest the skin. How much medical malpractice insurance do you have? Do you know that surgeons don't have to carry medical malpractice insurance? Crazy huh? In the end, if you do choose on a Phalloplasty, be smart about it, you are worth it, at least I think you are. A person that endures the most obstacles in life can offer the most to a society. Being different affords tremendous obstacles and you have a lot to offer the world because of it. You are worth a great surgeon, you are worth a great life, you are worth all your hopes and dreams. Unfortunately, the vast amount of our society is not going to feel the same way, its just the facts. Protect yourself and love yourself and count on yourself, because in the end it’s all that you have. Original Link

  • TReVoices - Parents/Detrans

    TReVoices Is The Leading Org Fighting To Stop Childhood Medical Transition World Wide! ​ Led by transman/lesbian Scott Newgent, our relentless SCREAMING to 'STOP Medically Transitioning Children' has been and continues to be heard everyday World - Wide! Make sure we can continue - We Need Your Help - Donate Today. Button Lift The Veil. Parents Get Busy & Learn Why 'Medical Transition Is Not Place For a child.' Sincerely, TReVoices & Everyone Else < Back Halley Morgan Original Article An Army Of Moms ​ An Army of Moms; 5 Things I Learned from the Frontlines of the Transgender Resistance An Army of Moms: 5 Things I Learned from the Frontlines of the Transgender Resistance Halley Morgan A few months ago, I joined a small group of parents of transgender kids. It has grown from a half dozen or so to more than eighty members and is still growing. The group is well-educated, highly intelligent, successful and caring. Supporting each other, using our significant skills in the areas of research, teaching, the law and medicine, and consulting with experts from around the globe, we are now an army of trans-realists with an artillery of science. My son, 16, told me he was transgender two years ago, but it did not make sense to me based on everything I had seen in him from birth. Now, it makes complete sense to me. More on that later. When I joined the group, I was struggling to figure out if being transgender was like being gay — which would merit total acceptance — or being anorexic, which my daughter suffered from at his age. He was not happy with his body, and was extremely anxious — so I saw similarities between the two. You may find that comparison offensive. But keep reading, and then tell me I’m wrong. Here’s what I’ve learned: 1. Trans-Realists Are Not “Transphobes” When I joined, I worried the group would be religious right and faith based. If it were, I would have silently exited. My worries were completely unfounded. We have political views from the right to the left. Among us are Catholics, Protestants, Jews, a Buddhist, and atheists like me too. There are various points of view in the group (as there should be) but the focus of the group is on scientific evidence to debunk the theory that the affirmation of transgender youth is always merited and to fight against the medicalization of those under 25. The other focus is to support each other. This isn’t always easy: it’s mentally challenging and lonely when you are not accepting the status quo presented by the transgender activists. We are from all over the country, and a few from overseas: we now have members from Florida, Texas, Ohio, Massachusetts, Illinois, Oregon, California, Australia, Canada, Sweden, England and Wales and more. Among us are gay couples, straight couples, divorced moms and dads. We have Ivy League degrees and the money and resources to start getting our voices heard. While we do not agree about everything, we are bound together by the knowledge that something has gone terribly wrong in the treatment of transgender youth presenting with gender dysphoria. It should not matter but I’d be considered on the “left.” I donated to Planned Parenthood (until they started these treatments), and to the ACLU too. Never again. The horrific reality of the medicalization of the spiking number of transgender youth is something that is much easier swept under the rug by a society that puts she/her/hers on email signatures — as if pronouns make the person. That said, if you are transgender, I support you and your legal rights 100% and your equal (actually more) protection under the law. While you may see it differently, not supporting medicalization of youth does not mean I do not value and support transgender individuals. 2. The State of Transgender Care is Much Worse than I Thought Being part of the group exposed me to the horrific reality of the skyrocketing number of transgender youths. Our kids have attended both private and public secondary schools, which “affirm” different names and pronouns for our kids without our permission — and sometimes without our knowledge. And yet giving them a Tylenol requires our consent. We all heard the same story from our boys, none of whom showed any signs of being transgender before. I’ve always known it. If you don’t affirm me, I’ll be taken away from you. Or I’ll commit suicide. We are constantly told by health professionals justifying putting our kids on experimental treatments that our kids will kill themselves if they do not transition but “do this or I will kill myself” is abusive logic and is generally not TRUE. There is no robust, high quality evidence that medically transitioning improves life satisfaction long term. Some studies show many who do transition have poor outcomes and a high risk of suicide. The stability of a self-reported transgender identity or a gender identity that departs from the traditional male-female binary among non-clinic-based populations remains unknown and requires further study. When my son “came out” as transgender, I was pressured to put him on puberty blockers to “give him time to decide.” I am so grateful I said no. These puberty blockers (Lupron, Triptodur) are experimental, are prescribed off label, cost thousands of dollars per month and have significant side effects such as stunted growth, lower density bones, and weaker tooth enamel. I knew I was not going to help my son change his body based on feelings that could change, but I did not know how bad things were. At 18, things get worse: hormone therapy, removal of testicles, breast implants, and converting penises into neo-vaginas. And, of course, giving up the ability to father a biological child in the natural way, and never having orgasms. For several moms in the group, their sons went off to colleges at prestigious colleges and universities and ended up getting prescribed hormones from student health centers practically as soon as they arrived with no meaningful medical evaluation. Another parent’s son — who has cancer and who lost his mom to cancer — went off to college at Rochester Institute of Technology (RIT). Despite being treated for cancer, the son’s self-diagnosis of gender dysphoria was met at the RIT student health center with, of course, immediate affirmation that he is indeed transgender and a referral to the University of Rochester Medical Center for hormone treatment. Luckily, his son’s oncologist stopped this, but the parent’s meetings with school medical professionals about this madness ended with the parent being admonished, saying he should fully support his son’s new gender identity. University administrators and the heads of their medical centers are completely complicit in the medicalization of their students. The safety and effectiveness of hormone treatment has not been demonstrated. Some hormonal dangers, e.g., to heart and fertility, are already known, but long term risks are unstudied. 3. Our Kids Are Amazingly Similar We’ve filled out charts of our boys. We found that many suffer from social anxiety and are unsure about their sexuality. Eighty-five percent of our sons are gifted, exceptionally gifted or profoundly gifted (IQ over 160). Fifteen percent have been diagnosed with autism and another 70% have one or more of the following: poor social skills, sensitivity issues and/or poor eye contact. None showed any gender confusion behavior prior to age 12. Many also have sensory overload issues and eating disorders (see above), as well. We have been talking to experts in the field of gender medicine from all over the world. One has told us that his male patients are generally autistic. These young people often see things in black and white. So, if they do not feel right as males, they must be females — paradoxical, given how they claim to reject gender stereotypes. It is circular thinking. When you ask them what being female means, few, if any, can answer. Many explode in anger. Cognitively they are very advanced, but may be relatively emotionally delayed. In puberty (some after growing a foot within a year) they feel bad about their bodies and go seeking answers on the internet and medicalization is presented as the solution to this issue. Social influence should not be dismissed when the spike in those presenting with gender dysphoria is so high. Our sons are white or mixed race, and socioeconomically privileged. It seems that, when you have that privilege, you have more time to ruminate about your gender. 4. Diagnoses are Crazy-Making All of our sons self-diagnosed themselves as having gender dysphoria. They did not show up to receive treatment for mental or physical distress and receive a diagnosis of “gender dysphoria.” Instead, with their self-diagnoses in hand, they show up to the offices of medical professionals. Within a session or two — bam — a “professional” is telling them they have gender dysphoria and depending on age, should start on puberty blockers or hormones. There is no examination of any underlying mental conditions or the distorted thinking that can come with them. Instead, gender dysphoria is given as a cause of the other illnesses rather than a result of them. Looking at the DSM-5 for Gender Dysphoria –many of us would have met the criteria for gender dysphoria during certain periods over the course of our lives. What doesn’t happen — and what, based on the experts I’ve listened to as part of the group should happen — is to deconstruct what they are thinking and feeling. Certainly they would not be there if they were not feeling distressed about their bodies and it is extremely important not to dismiss their feelings. We parents have found it virtually impossible to find any such care. In certain locales (including Australia) any questioning at all of the self-diagnosis of gender dysphoria is seen as conversion therapy. Gender identity is equated with sexual orientation. Transgender is seen as the new gay. But being gay does not involve a lifetime of medicalization. While being transgender is not widely considered an “illness”, gender dysphoria is; and insurance companies, including for those on Medicaid, pay for the expensive “gender-affirming” treatments. An established clinic in Chicago diagnoses “endocrine disorders” for perfectly healthy natal males (trans females) because they do not have estrogen levels like natal females. With that kind of thinking, they might as well be described as having chromosome disorders, too. My son can’t get medical treatment until he is 18 and he says he won’t after. You do not know the relief that gives me. So you may wonder why any of this still matters to me. Well, first, he may change his mind, and second I believe that initial diagnosis of “gender dysphoria” has harmed him in more ways than the therapist will ever know. He has told me that because the therapist said it, it is true and he should continue to use his female name and pronouns and dress, which all in themselves may leave him too embarrassed to desist later even if he wants to. More than that, I’m worried about the sons of my new friends and about all youth who may or may not find this was the right path for them. 5. People Do Regret Transitioning; Lawsuits are Coming We are told no one regrets transitioning. Not only is there no evidence to back that up, the number of detransitioners and desisters is in fact growing, demonstrating a need to re-evaluate the medicalization of transgender youth. I am trying to help two young men seek legal recourse against medical professionals who failed to provide warnings, failed to address other mental health issues, and failed to allow time for them to contemplate such life altering decisions. Instead, transgender activists stood by, telling them exactly what to say to get treatments and how to defeat anything which got in their way — including taking a reasonable amount of time to think about what they wanted. They were both prescribed hormones, had their testicles surgically removed and had breasts implanted in rapid succession. They soon realized that, while their other mental health issues remained, the diagnosis of gender dysphoria was wrong. Insurance paid for the breast implants (costing $20K), they had to pay to have them removed. There are various groups of lawyers from around the country who are readying cases. There is too much money being made from too many people, and we believe one of the only ways to stop this madness is through the law. And lawsuits mean damages. The evidence we’ve presented is dismissed categorically as “transphobic” — even by so-called specialists in the field. Where else would you find that language from “professionals”? So, no matter how many comments calling me a “transphobe” I get here, and no matter how quickly my article may be taken down — the Army of Trans-Realists is growing, and we are going to be heard.

  • TReVoices - Parents/Detrans

    TReVoices Is The Leading Org Fighting To Stop Childhood Medical Transition World Wide! ​ Led by transman/lesbian Scott Newgent, our relentless SCREAMING to 'STOP Medically Transitioning Children' has been and continues to be heard everyday World - Wide! Make sure we can continue - We Need Your Help - Donate Today. Button Lift The Veil. Parents Get Busy & Learn Why 'Medical Transition Is Not Place For a child.' Sincerely, TReVoices & Everyone Else < Back Detrans Canada Member A. Original Article DETRANS CANADA ​ Canadian Detransitioners Tell Their Stories I knew I liked girls from a young age. But I could never last in a long-term relationship. Since high school, when my gender dysphoria was most prominent, I would end relationships without explanation. I would just tell them we can’t be together, without explaining that I had issues with my body; that I couldn’t let them see or touch my body. I felt like I was inadequate or incomplete as a lesbian. I felt like I must be a man to be legitimate, or I must have male parts before I can have sex. I felt like I was doing something wrong, like I was “converting” them to lesbianism, or “making” them lesbian. I felt as if it was awful to be a lesbian and it was all my fault, even though they were willingly dating me because they were attracted to me, and I had not fooled or coerced them in anyway. I hate myself for being a masculine girl, a lesbian, and I felt like it was all my fault, so I would cut and burn myself, and drink heavily, to make it all go away. A few of the girls who liked me, and would attempt to date me, would be sad and cry. They could not understand why I hated myself and my body so much. They would try to tell me that it was okay, that they knew I was a lesbian. They wanted to touch me, in the same way I touched them, but I wouldn’t let them. I thought I had to be a man to make them happy. I thought I had to be their husband, and have children with them, for it to be legitimate. I thought every girl was straight and wanted a heterosexual life, and since I could not give that to them, I would beat myself up about it. I never got therapy for my internalized homophobia. No one made the connection. The symptoms of my internalized homophobia matched those of gender dysphoria, so professionals just assumed I was a man trapped inside a woman’s body somehow. They offered me transition, as a way to “correct” my body, instead of helping me cope with my emotions. I started testosterone when I was 23. The therapist who wrote my letter was a trans man. He asked whether I had internalized homophobia, and I answered “no”. We didn’t delve into it any further. I honestly didn’t even understand what exactly he was asking. The endocrinologist who prescribed my hormones told me about the side effects: increased muscle mass, facial and body hair, voice drop – these were the effects that I wanted. He also briefly mentioned side effects like acne, increased blood pressure, and infertility, but I didn’t think about that. I told him that I didn’t want to have children anyway, and that I was happy to have all the good and bad that comes with being a man; I was committed. I began Androgel on my birthday that month because I saw it as a “rebirth”, as if I was going to become a new person, or as if I would be reborn again, in the right body this time. The first few months were really good. I got everything that I wanted. My shoulders got wider, my hips narrowed. I began developing facial and body hair, and my voice dropped. I was already passing as a boy before testosterone, but this helped me pass 100% of the time. I had more energy and my mood improved. This is what is known to detransitioners as the honeymoon period. After about 6 or 8 months, everything changed. I was constantly hungry and couldn’t keep up with my increased libido. My mental health worsened. Prior to starting testosterone I had been diagnosed with Bipolar 1 Disorder, and Borderline Personality Disorder. I became so aggressive at home that my parents called the police a few times, because I was shouting, threatening, and destroying their house. I dropped out of school, which meant that I had to switch to injections because my insurance ran out. I was not able to work and I went into psychosis, which meant I was in and out of the psych ward constantly over a period of 7 years. While in the psych ward, I told them that I was on Hormone Replacement Therapy, and asked whether that could be affecting my mental health, but they dismissed it. They said the two were unrelated. I didn’t know at the time but have since learned that it is a well established that synthetic hormones can cause mental health issues in females. They continued injecting me with testosterone in the hospital, but gave me anti-psychotics to stabilize my moods. I was dysfunctional. I ended up homeless because I was misbehaving at home. No one cared about my quality of life. All the doctor’s primary concern was always whether I passed or not, as a male. I did, so they considered my transition a success. I started to look up “detransition”. I wanted to know whether I could stop, or if there was a way back. I found a few detransitioners online. I didn’t recognize myself in the mirror or photos. I looked as if I was my own male cousin. I decided to stop testosterone without telling my doctor. I was afraid how they would react. My endocrinologist had not taken my concerns seriously. My family doctor didn’t care which way I went in my transition. They acted like it didn’t matter; like any identity is valid no matter what it does to your health. There is no support for detransitioning. Every time I went to speak to a doctor or therapist, they all concluded the same thing: that I was trans, and I must stay on my hormone regimen. Me wanting to desist or stop, was seen as me being unwell, and not taking my medicine. If I explained that the hormones seemed to be making my mental health worse, they would shame and coerce me into taking them again anyway. CAMH approved me for top surgery twice, but both times, the funding ran out because I was not able to do the surgery in time. My mental health was so bad that my psychiatrist would not write the readiness letter for surgery. CAMH kept pressuring me to get surgery. They would say: “we have approved you twice. How come you are not getting the surgery?” Or knowing that I had not gotten the surgery yet, they would push for more surgery. They would ask: “when are you getting your hysterectomy? What about bottom surgery?” When I first detransitioned, I was very confused, and was trying to live as my birth sex, but using female washrooms was impossible, since I now passed so much as a male. From my perspective, living as my birth sex was impossible. I tried to go to school again, and the school counsellor came to the same conclusion: “You are transgender. This is why you are having these difficulties.” At every step they affirmed my trans identity, and they kept sending me back to the same doctors or the same organizations that had transitioned me the first time. In order to detransition, I had to change my entire health care team. It was only then that any doctors could look at my medical history critically and comment on the pattern of taking hormones leading me to experience several mental health issues. I lived as a trans man for 10 years and took testosterone. I am thirty one now, and this is the first time that I am starting to see the connection between my internalized homophobia, and my desire to be a “straight man” or rather to pass as a straight man in society. I will never truly be a man in the way that a natal male is a man, as I was led to believe when I began my transition. I will never have functional male genitalia or be able to father children. I have a female body and experienced female socialization, and no matter how I try to alter my body with hormones and surgeries, I could only ever be an approximation of a male while running from the reality of being a homosexual female. For the first time in my life, I am in a lesbian relationship with someone who is attracted to me exactly as I am, and that has made a huge difference. She doesn’t wish I was a male, so I don’t wish I was a male either. This lesbian relationship where I am seen as my true self, where I don’t have to make any alterations to my body, and can just exist as I am, has been tremendously healing for me. I wish other gays and lesbians with extreme internalized homophobia like myself can find self love without feeling the need to fit into the heterosexual world through transition.

  • TReVoices - SCREAMING In The Media

    < Back Children's Rights, Trans Realities | with Scott Newgent Scott Newgent & Benjamin Boyce US Scott Newgent (@TReVoices) is a transman who is very concerned that the current fast-track of childhood medical transition is going to lead to some dire and unintended consequences. Find out more on Scott's Work: https://www.trevoices.org Find him on twitter @TReCVoices.org Support this channel: https://www.paypal.me/benjaminboyce Original Link

  • TReVoices - SCREAMING In The Media

    < Back Interview with Trans Man & Leading International Phycologist On Childhood Gender Dysphoria Interview With Leading International Phycotherapist Stella O’Malley & Scott Newgent International 1111 Original Link

  • TReVoices - SCREAMING In The Media

    < Back France - Journal d'investigation - Tendance transgenre Abigial Shrier - Transman Scott Newgent en vedette - Abigail Shrier & Scott Newgent France 111 Original Link

  • TReVoices - SCREAMING In The Media

    < Back Trans Man is Twitter-banned after speaking against gender transition of children By, Barbara Kay Canada It was bound to happen sooner or later. It happened a week ago. Scott Newgent, a 48 year old female to male trans man, has been banned for life from Twitter. His crime was to issue explicit warnings about the risks to gender-dysphoric children from puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones, as well as the potential horrors that can accompany gender-reassignment surgery, which he underwent five years ago. Since he overcame an initial reluctance to go public with his story two years ago, Scott, who has three children of his own, has dedicated himself heart and soul to the mission of educating under-informed parents and deterring children from early commitment to medicalized gender crossover. Scott says what most people believe, but are now too cowed to say aloud: Underage children have not got the competence or objectivity to assess their own psychological situation or to understand the scope of what a lifetime dependency on cross-sex drugs, let alone sex reassignment surgery, implies for the human body. Scott's own cautionary tale is a medical horror story. His riveting journey has been graphically chronicled—by himself or others—in publications such as Quillette, National Review, Newsweek and Catholic Weekly. As he summarizes it in Quillette: "During my own transition, I had seven surgeries. I also had a massive pulmonary embolism, a helicopter life-flight ride, an emergency ambulance ride, a stress-induced heart attack, sepsis, a 17-month recurring infection due to using the wrong skin during a (failed) phalloplasty, 16 rounds of antibiotics, three weeks of daily IV antibiotics, the loss of all my hair, (only partially successful) arm reconstructive surgery, permanent lung and heart damage, a cut bladder, insomnia-induced hallucinations—oh and frequent loss of consciousness due to pain from the hair on the inside of my urethra. All this led to a form of PTSD that made me a prisoner in my apartment for a year. Between me and my insurance company, medical expenses exceeded $900,000," Scott writes. "During these 17 months of agony, I couldn't get a urologist to help me. They didn't feel comfortable taking me on as a patient—since the phalloplasty, like much of the transition process, is experimental." Scott's surgeon has often been named, but I won't, because even though numerous patients have lodged complaints about their botched surgeries by him, that surgeon isn't the point here, so I don't need to risk a defamation suit. (In my opinion, that surgeon should never see the inside of an operating theatre again, but he is still practising.) The point is that, as Scott writes, "trans health doesn't really have a justiciable baseline." If a surgeon botches your gall bladder operation, there are criteria by which to judge him or her. Or mastectomies, a relatively simple and straightforward procedure. But, although increasingly common nowadays, "bottom surgery," still relatively rare compared to most surgeries, is extremely complex and fraught with potential downsides, even those done by competent surgeons. Not all gender dysphoric children go on to bottom surgery as adults, but gender dysphoric adults are the only people who get bottom surgery. The risks associated with these surgeries is something the "affirming" community should be—but are not—communicating to parents of dysphoric children. Instead, parents are led to believe that the lifelong medical interventions they are guiding their children toward (it is well known now that virtually all children who take puberty blockers go on to cross-sex hormones) are a benign sidebar to the holy grail of gender transition. One might argue that as long as bottom surgery is something only adults agree to, it is their responsibility to assess the risks, and should not be the concern of those treating children. Perhaps Scott should have been suspicious that, as he told me in an interview, his initial call to the surgeon only lasted four minutes and his consultation in person eight minutes before committing to the surgery. But the fact that the surgeon himself did not ensure that Scott was fully informed of the gravity and risks associated with the surgery tells you something about the sex-reassignment "industry," a fair term given the lucrative rewards for pharmaceutical companies and doctors, and the lax regulations around it. It also tells you that even an intelligent adult who has proved himself a winner in other areas of his life can act with extraordinary naivete and "white coat"-inspired trust when his mind is fixated on what he believes to be an existential need. You might think that someone like Scott, with "lived experience" on the frontlines of full transition, would enjoy respect and deference in the debate over early affirmation of children with gender dysphoria. But since he is offering a perspective trans activists don't want to hear, he has been—much like the growing number of detransitioners – shunned as an apostate by those who control the public narrative. I call those movement leaders who dictate the gender heresy criteria to Twitter and mainstream media the "gender mystics." They promote gender dysphoria in children as a sign that the child has been "chosen" for membership in a higher order of human life. From the encouragement and deference paid to even slightly gender-confused children by the trans movement's acolytes in the teaching and therapeutic professions—and their gaslighted parents—you would think they were all mini-Dalai Lamas, emanating a special glow of holiness that confers blessings on everyone in their orbit. Any deviation from the utterly harmless sanctification model is considered "transphobia" by the gender mystics, and they have social media lined up in genuflection at the communion rail to prove their obeisance to the dogma. Meanwhile, social media's fear of facilitating alleged transphobia is worse than their concern about facilitating other forms of hate, such as antisemitism. The Center for Countering Digital Hate found that Twitter and Facebook took down fewer than one in nine reported examples of antisemitism over a six-week period in 2021. The posts include Holocaust denial, Nazi symbolism, and hashtags like #holohoax and #killthejews. There is nothing radical and certainly nothing objectively transphobic about what Scott has to say. He does not deny that gender dysphoria exists. He understands that there are some children—not many—for whom puberty blockers may be indicated as necessary. But instant affirmation and encouragement for off-label meds should never be the default response to gender confusion, even though "conversion therapy" bills like C-6 in Canada (not yet passed by the Senate) are conceived with the intention of making anything but affirmation and meds the norm in gender dysphoria therapy. Scott has a tough-love message for parents that is intended to make them feel guilty rather than compassionate and loving when they fall into the instant-affirmation trap. "For parents, I would say this," Scott writes, "It is simply not your right or duty to decide to medically transition your child. Remove that burden from your mind. Medical transition is for adults. The negatives associated with medical transition are vast, and you won't be the one who lives with the consequences. It will be your child. If your child tells you they will kill themselves if you do not allow them to medically transition (perhaps following a script he or she is provided on Reddit or Tumblr), take them to the hospital so they can be treated for suicidal ideation. Suicidal ideation and seeking transition are separate issues, so separate them." Scott is not the first courageous member of the trans sanity brigade to be Twitter-shamed, and he won't be the last. But he is endowed with the gladiatorial spirit that battens on challenge. Exile from Twitter tilts the playing field against dissent, but passionately engaged fighters (especially those in the United Kingdom) find other ways to get their message out. Graham Linehan, a brilliant English comedian, writer and director, broke away from a successful show business career to immerse himself in muckraking the sewer of pathological misogyny that is unfortunately part and parcel of trans activism, but one the movement leaders refuse to own. Twitter-banned as of June, 2020, Linehan runs a Substack that provides reliable, although often dismaying information not recommended for the faint of heart. Maya Forstater was fired from her think-tank job and was temporarily banned from Twitter for expressing her opinion "that sex is immutable and not to be conflated with gender identity." She first lost, but ultimately won a recent tribunal appeal– setting a significant precedent – when it was judged that her "gender-critical beliefs" fell under the Equalities Act as they "did not seek to destroy the rights of trans persons." Another lawsuit is in the works: James Esses is a former criminal defence barrister who chose to train as a therapist. In May 2021, three years into his degree program, Esses was expelled from the Metanoia institute (accredited by Middlesex University). According to Esses, "The reason for my expulsion was that I had been trying to safeguard therapy and counselling for vulnerable children with gender dysphoria. I had lodged a public petition, which subsequently got 10,000 signatures and a response from the government, who agreed to many of the safeguards I had been seeking. The petition caused a social media backlash against me and culminated in my expulsion. My course provider needlessly publicised the expulsion on social media. I worry that this has therefore ended my career in my chosen profession before it has even begun." Esses is fighting back. He started a crowdfunding campaign to raise funds for a lawsuit and as of August 1, had raised 30 thousand pounds. Maya Forstater's victory is likely to weigh heavily in his case. It is important that we do not automatically assume that exile from Twitter is an insurmountable barrier to resistance. The gender mystics are winning social media battles, but the war will be won by the heroes who refuse to yield to their tyranny, who refuse to be silenced, and who find other pathways to make their case. The sane people, those who refuse to be gaslighted, must support them in any way we can. TRE Voices, which stands for Trans Rational Educational Voices, is Scott Newgent's newsletter. Do visit and sign up. Original Link

  • TReVoices - Parents/Detrans

    TReVoices Is The Leading Org Fighting To Stop Childhood Medical Transition World Wide! ​ Led by transman/lesbian Scott Newgent, our relentless SCREAMING to 'STOP Medically Transitioning Children' has been and continues to be heard everyday World - Wide! Make sure we can continue - We Need Your Help - Donate Today. Button Lift The Veil. Parents Get Busy & Learn Why 'Medical Transition Is Not Place For a child.' Sincerely, TReVoices & Everyone Else < Back Abigail Shrier Original Article EYE ON THE NEWS Writer, Author: IRREVERSIBLE DAMAGE: The Transgender Craze Seducing Our Daughters (2020). Named to "Best Books" lists by the Economist, Times of London philosophicalinvestigations@protonmail.com When the State Comes for Your Kids by Abigail Shrier Ahmed is a Pakistani immigrant, a faithful Muslim, and until recently, a financial consultant to Seattle’s high-tech sector. But when he reached me by phone in October 2020, he was just one more frightened father. Days earlier, he and his wife had checked their 16-year-old son into Seattle Children’s Hospital for credible threats of suicide. Now, Ahmed was worried that the white coats who had gently admitted his son to their care would refuse to return him. “They sent an email to us, you know, ‘you should take your ‘daughter’ to the gender clinic,’” he told me. At first, Ahmed (I have changed names in this essay to protect the identities of minor children) assumed there had been a mistake. He had dropped off a son, Syed, to the hospital, in a terrible state of distress. Now, the email he received from the mental health experts used a new name for that son and claimed he was Ahmed’s daughter. “They were trying to create a customer for their gender clinic . . . and they seemed to absolutely want to push us in that direction,” he said when I spoke to him again this May, recalling the horror of last October. “We had calls with counselors and therapists in the establishment, telling us how important it is for him to change his gender, because that’s the only way he’s going to be better out of this suicidal depressive state.” Syed had been a “straight-A student” and—according to his parents and the family’s therapist—quite brilliant. He is also on the autism spectrum, a young man who neglects to make eye contact and must be given rules for how long to shake hands, shower, or brush his teeth. High school was a slog for him, as it often is for kids on the spectrum who find that the social demands of adolescence have risen beyond their capacity to meet them. “He tried to ask a few girls out. It didn’t work out and he got frustrated and angry, and that kind of thing. And so, those girl-boy things get kind of tough for autistic kids, those developmental issues. And that’s where puberty can be very, very hard with the hormones rushing and all this stuff.” When lockdowns hit, the boy who was already struggling socially and befuddled by questions neurotypical teens take for granted (How do I show a girl I like her? How do I make the other kids include me?) began to spend all day and night on the Internet. “He’s an autistic kid, and so he kind of lost track of time. And he was staying up a lot. So he was staying up, just being on the Internet, Twitter, Tumblr, whatever. . . . And he was in his room, just, you know, sleeping one or two hours a day. And that can really be devastating. He was very confused. He was seeing things, visual hallucinations. And we didn’t know why.” It is not definitively known why many neurodiverse adolescents identify as transgender, but more than one scientist has pointed out the high rates of coincidence. As several autism experts have explained to me, those on the spectrum tend to fixate, and when a contagious idea is introduced to them—such as the notion that they might be a “girl in a boy’s body”—they are particularly susceptible to it. As child psychiatrist and expert in gender dysphoria Susan Bradley said to me: “The messages these kids pick up [from trans influencers] when they’re online is, ‘We’re the only people who understand you. Your people, your parents, don’t really understand you.’ And it may be the first time in their lives that anybody has said to them, ‘We understand you. We know you. You’re okay. You’re just like us.’ And it’s powerful.” I asked Bradley if introducing gender ideology to kids who tend to fixate is like introducing cocaine to those susceptible to addiction. She agreed: “It has the same power to assuage all the alienation and grief and distress that these kids have been struggling with.” Because of a Covid-19 policy, Ahmed could not stay at the hospital with his son back in October. Syed, in a sleep-deprived and confused state, furious at the parents who had admitted him, and in consultation with hospital staff and a social worker, decided that his problem was gender. The age at which minors in the State of Washington can receive mental health and gender-affirming care without parental permission is 13. In other words, the emails Ahmed received from the hospital were effectively a courtesy; the hospital did not require Ahmed’s permission to begin his son on a path to medical transition. But unlike some other parents I would later speak with, Ahmed’s cool head prevailed. Believing he might be walking into a trap, Ahmed reached out to both a lawyer and a psychiatrist friend he trusted. The psychiatrist gave him advice that he believes saved his son, saying, in Ahmed’s words: “You have to be very, very careful, because if you come across as just even a little bit anti-trans or anything, they’re going to call the Child Protective Services on you and take custody of your kid.” The lawyer told Ahmed the same: “What you want to do is agree with them and take your kid home. When the gender counselors advise you to ‘affirm,’ go along with it. Just say ‘Uh-huh, uh-huh, okay, let’s take him home, and we’ll go to the gender clinic.’” Ahmed assured Seattle Children’s Hospital that he would take his son to a gender clinic and commence his son’s transition. Instead, he collected his son, quit his job, and moved his family of four out of Washington. Was Ahmed’s reaction extreme? When I first heard it, back in October 2020, I wondered whether he hadn’t overreacted. But as a growing number of parents began contacting me with similar stories, and I delved into the state laws of Washington, Oregon, and California, I came to a different conclusion. Taken individually, no single law in any state completely strips parents’ rights over the care and mental health treatment of their troubled minor teens. But pieced together, laws in California, Oregon, and Washington place troubled minor teens as young as 13 in the driver’s seat when it comes to their own mental health care—including “gender affirming” care—and renders parents powerless to stop them. Here, for instance, are the powers granted to a 13-year-old child by the state of Washington. Minors age 13 and up are entitled to admit themselves for inpatient and outpatient mental health treatment without parental consent. Health insurers are forbidden from disclosing to the insured parents’ sensitive medical information of minor children—such as that regarding “gender dysphoria [and] gender affirming care.” Minors aged 13 to 18 can withhold mental health records from parents for “sensitive” conditions, which include both “gender dysphoria” and “gender-affirming care.” Insurers in Washington must cover a wide array of “gender-affirming treatments” from tracheal shaves to double mastectomies. Put these together, and a seventh grader could be entitled to embark on “gender affirming care”—which may include anything from a provider using the child’s name and pronouns to the kid preparing to receive a course of hormones—without her parents’ permission, against her parents’ wishes, covered by her parents’ insurance, and with the parents kept in the dark by insurance companies and medical providers. Lest you wonder whether there is some madcap elixir polluting the groundwater of Washington State alone, in 2015, Oregon passed a law permitting minors 15 and older to obtain puberty blockers, cross-sex hormones, and surgeries at taxpayers’ expense—all without parental consent. In 2018, California passed a similar bill for all children in foster care, age 12 and up. The California state senate is now considering an amendment to the Confidentiality of Medical Information Act that would bar health insurers from disclosing medical information to parents about their dependents, on pain of criminal liability. One Washington mother I spoke with, Nicole, has a 16-year-old daughter who struggled with an eating disorder and other mental health problems after being molested by a peer in elementary school. Just before her 13th birthday, the daughter decided she was transgender. “She hated her body, that was truly a real thing,” Nicole told me. “So we wanted to find her help.” But Nicole wasn’t convinced that her daughter had gender dysphoria, since she’d never before shown any signs of discomfort with her biological sex. “She had already been through a whole counseling program with the eating disorder and none of this came up.” Over the next few years, Nicole’s daughter’s mental health worsened, and she began self-harming. After her daughter attempted suicide in 2019, Nicole took her to the emergency room at Highline Hospital (now St. Anne Hospital) in Burien, Washington. Nicole explained to the social worker at the hospital that, though the daughter was insisting her problem was gender, she’d been beset by a variety of mental health struggles for many years. Nicole said that she and her husband were not convinced by the gender dysphoria self-diagnosis and did not “affirm” their daughter’s trans identity. “The social worker was very nice to us,” Nicole told me. “She didn’t show any indication that she was not believing what we were saying or anything like that.” But a nurse attending Nicole’s daughter who had been through the same thing with his own daughter took pity on Nicole and her husband. When the social worker left the room, Nicole says, he warned them that she was on the way to “emancipate” their child. Washington law does not allow a minor to petition for emancipation until age 16. But according to several parents I spoke with, under the guise of “advising transgender youth of their rights,” social workers will sometimes sprinkle that tidbit onto a 14-year-old, so she knows liberation is only two years away. Nicole and her husband didn’t wait. They immediately took her home. That was probably a good thing. Her daughter had full rights to go to a shelter where, had she elected to, she could be “affirmed” and started on a path toward medical transition. And, as it turns out, once a troubled teen over the age of 13 elects to stay in a shelter in Washington, it can be fiendishly difficult to extract them. Instead, more than a year later, Nicole reports that her daughter is much better, as is their relationship. The daughter has dropped the idea that she is transgender and is tapering off of anti-depressants. Julie’s troubled 14-year-old daughter never identified as transgender. But Julie’s account of her tussle with Washington social workers and youth shelters—the details of which are corroborated by two different police reports—sheds critical light on the state’s approach to at-risk teens aged 13 and up. Julie specifically asked to go on the record about her experience—that’s how angry she is about what happened to her. I’ve masked her last name only to protect her minor daughter, Kayla. Kayla had long suffered severe mood swings, anxiety, and depression, stemming from childhood trauma at the hands of a father who sexually abused her. Though a no-contact court order has kept Julie’s ex-husband away from his daughter for several years, the girl’s depression began spiking in recent months, and she developed worrying signs of mental instability; according to Julie, Kayla’s current therapist has described these symptoms as “textbook borderline personality disorder.” On March 17, 2021, Julie dropped her daughter off at church youth group. At around 8 PM, Julie received a call from the pastor that Kayla had threatened to kill herself by overdosing on pills. Kayla didn’t actually have any pills on her, according to the police report filed that day, but she had announced her intention to procure some. When Julie headed to the church, her daughter ran away. The pastor drove Kayla straight to the emergency room at Seattle Children’s Hospital, where she was admitted. Because of the pandemic, Julie was not allowed into the hospital room with Kayla, but at some point during her daughter’s stay, Julie believes a social worker at the hospital suggested to Kayla that if she didn’t want to go home, she had the right to stay at a youth shelter. After a night in the hospital, Kayla called her pastor and asked to be driven to the YouthCare Hope Center, a shelter for the protection of kids, ages 12 to 17, experiencing homelessness, abuse, or extreme family conflict. When the hospital called Julie to tell her that Kayla was asking to stay at a homeless shelter, Julie was horrified. “I said, ‘Well, that’s, that’s absurd. She has a home, she has a family who loves her. Clearly, you’re not sending CPS—we’ve done nothing wrong. She doesn’t need to go to shelter.’ And the [hospital staff member] said, ‘Well, she’s 14, so she gets to make that choice for herself.’” The staff member was right that Kayla had a right to check herself in for inpatient treatment (though the worker was wrong that this particular YouthCare center qualified). Once Kayla got there, extracting her proved a nightmare. Unless Kayla voluntarily exited the shelter, Julie could neither see her daughter nor take her home. And it is very clear that Julie’s daughter did not want to return home to mom. Among their several mother–daughter disagreements, Kayla was furious with her mother for the rules Julie had established for Internet use. There were boys with whom Kayla conducted online relationships, which Julie worried about; Julie feared that some of these friendships were with adult men posing online as teens. She had attempted to cut off Kayla’s ability to communicate with them. According to Seattle police officer Nathan Bauer’s report, shelter social worker Micaela Leavell was aware that Julie did not want her daughter at the facility. But Leavell told the officer that she “felt it was better” if the girl remained at the shelter because the daughter “feels ‘unsafe’ at her mother’s house.” Officer Bauer noted that Leavell “could not elaborate on any specific concerns” that the girl mentioned other than she “stated she would harm herself if she were returned.” If Julie’s daughter had concrete reasons for “feeling unsafe” in her mother’s home, she seems never to have provided them to any of the bevy of mental health care or social workers who attended her. Several times a day, for the next few days, Julie called the YouthCare shelter to speak with her daughter. Each time, she was told that her daughter did not want to speak with her. At this point, Julie operated under a cloud of belief that the social workers at the shelter had her daughter’s best interest at heart. But Julie retained her daughter’s cell phone. She saw the messages coming in and out, apparently sent by her daughter from a computer at the shelter. And she saw that her daughter had sent the following message to a youth pastor: “Hey! I’m pretty sure I found a lawyer that will help me to stay in the [shelter] program since my social worker/case manager highly suggested that I find one as soon as possible cause he is worried that my mom will try to pull me out.” Julie realized her daughter seemed to be working toward legal emancipation, with the help of a lawyer arranged by the shelter. Julie later learned that the shelter had found her daughter an attorney and was working to try and file a Child in Need of Services petition. This would have made the shelter Kayla’s legal guardian, for all practical purposes. Indeed, several parents of trans-identified teens told me that the social workers who had attended to their daughters during a mental health crisis or suicide attempt had begun coaching their daughters on “emancipation,” under the guise of “advising them of their rights.” Many of the social workers encouraged the idea in psychologically vulnerable teens—who likely welcomed the suggestion—that their parents’ rules, decisions, and objections to the teens’ behavior constituted “abuse,” the parents said. Officer Bauer’s report, regarding the case of Julie and her daughter Kayla, tends to corroborate this. Kayla’s case manager, Oscar, volunteered to the police that YouthCare staff “provides the children with information on resources and courses of action, like emancipation, when asked by clients.” (I emailed Oscar to find out how much “asking” a teen needs to do before a social worker suggests emancipation, but I never received a response.) The published Washington State Department of Children, Youth & Families guidance informs children’s administration staff that they are not permitted to disclose a child’s LGBTQ+ identities to the parents; instructs them to use forms that “clearly distinguish the legal name and gender from chosen name and gender,” presumably to prevent accidental slip-ups on the secret understanding they’ve established with a child to her parents; and requires them to refer a child or youth who wants to participate to “LGBTQ+ related services,” including “behavioral health and medical providers that affirm their identity.” Lest you think that “affirming” by a medical provider merely entails use of name and pronouns, the guidance defines “Gender Affirming” as “medical procedures that changes [sic] a person’s body to conform to their gender identity.” In the end, it would take a team of eight officers to remove Julie’s daughter forcibly from the shelter. By that time, Julie already had a plan for Kayla’s treatment—in Arizona, where Kayla now resides in an inpatient treatment center for suicidality and depression. But the first order of business was to extract her daughter from Washington. If you’re familiar with the traditional model of youth shelters, you might assume that they are filled with kids whose parents either didn’t want them or subjected them to abuse. But as the definition of “abuse” has expanded to mean everything from physically harming a child to not “affirming” a child’s newly proclaimed gender identity, youth shelters seem to have ballooned to house even children from stable, loving families who desperately want their children back. In 2012, agencies responding to a Williams Institute at UCLA Law survey reported that about 40 percent of the homeless young people they served identified as LGBTQ. From this bare statistic, many infer that LGBTQ teens are being frequently kicked out of their homes by bigoted parents. Far from it. I asked Alexa Goodenow, an outreach worker at the SafePlace for Youth crisis hotline, which connects at-risk youth with a network of Seattle shelters, what challenges LGBTQ+ youth face that lead them to a shelter. “I would say one of the most common things that we see is just that cultural disconnect between them and their support system,” she said. “So, hypothetically speaking, maybe a young person who’s now identifying as non-binary or coming out as maybe gay or lesbian and bisexual and maybe families aren’t supportive of that. So we do see a lot of that because in the Seattle area, we get a lot of melting pot of backgrounds. So maybe the young person’s views don’t quite align with their at-home support.” Being a teenager is no picnic. But removing minor children from their parents’ home didn’t used to be a matter of a parent–child “cultural disconnect”—or the young person’s views not “quite align[ing] with their at-home support.” The point was to provide sanctuary for children who would otherwise suffer physical harm or psychological torment. Today, a teenager can declare an LGBTQ identity that is unsupported in her home and claim that this lack of support puts her mental health at risk. “For our young people experiencing homelessness, over 90 percent of them cite family conflict as a cause of homelessness,” said Suzanne Sullivan, Chief Advancement Officer at YouthCare, who confirmed for me that almost 30 percent of the young people at her shelter identify as LGBTQ+. “We see a lot of young people who have different sexual identities or gender identities that are not supported at home. At YouthCare, we believe that every young person deserves to live their life to the fullest and that includes gender and sexual identity. We are affirming at all of our locations and we don’t feel that it’s acceptable not to be,” she said. YouthCare houses adolescents and young adults ages 12 to 24. For child services in states that regard “gender affirming care” as the only humane way to treat a troubled teen who’s suddenly decided she’s transgender, the power the state grants them to undermine and even remove parents who object to these treatments is alarming. I asked Sullivan if the teens who come to YouthCare are being abused at home. “There are a lot of individual young people, so each story is unique and each story is different. And there are all different forms of mistreatment and neglect and abandonment. In some cases, kids are kicked out. In some cases, they leave.” In a state that grants minors aged 13 and up control over their mental health treatment—in a society that increasingly defines “abuse” as any of a variety of limits a parent might place on the gender or sexual exploration of a minor—it is easy enough for a troubled teen to decide that parents are “bad for my mental health.” A credible threat of suicide seems sufficient to earn a child an indefinite right to stay in a youth shelter, where she can hang out with other teens and free herself from meaningful supervision. (I spoke with one parent outside of Washington whose troubled 15-year-old was able to smoke marijuana and develop an alcohol problem at a youth shelter, according to a psychiatric evaluation I reviewed. In Julie’s case, she told me that, while Kayla was at the YouthCare shelter, she was often able to skip Zoom school.) After Sullivan refused to answer more questions over the phone, I emailed her for comment on the claim by parents that “once their teens choose to stay at one of the shelters, if they are over 13, they are hard to extract.” Sullivan—who many times during our call invited me to email her with questions—wrote back to say that she had no comment. It isn’t hard to see why a rebellious teen struggling with mental health problems might not want to return home from a youth shelter, even to a loving family. Take Lambert House, a “safe place for lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, and questioning (LGBTQ) youth ages 11-22,” according to its website. Activities include “Minecraft,” “Poetry Slam / Art Share,” “Saturday Night Lambert Live!” and “Boys Who Like Boys Group.” That might seem like a fun set of social activities for college students. It’s a little more troubling to consider that, based on a perusal of the activities calendar, many of the events seem to facilitate socializing between 22-year-olds and adolescents as young as 11. I called Lambert House several times for clarification, but never received a call back. I did, however, speak with Vernadette Broyles, president and founder of Child and Parental Rights Campaign. A Harvard-educated lawyer, Broyles represents parents in child custody, child protective services, and school cases. I asked Broyles point-blank: Was she seeing the same the pattern I had noticed—namely, loving parents bringing a suicidal, trans-identified teen to the E.R., which ensnares her in a child services network that will not relinquish her? “Yes, that is one of the patterns,” she said. “We’re seeing national patterns. . . . One is the very deliberate and systemic erosion of parental rights.” Broyles believes that this erosion leaves girls, especially, “disproportionately vulnerable.” According to the parents I’ve talked with, it’s hard to argue with that. One mother I spoke with had had Child Protective Services called on her by her own therapist, after she had explained in therapy why she had chosen not to “affirm” her young trans-identified teen daughter. In that instance, the mom said, the social worker accepted the mother’s explanation that this did not constitute abuse. She counts herself lucky. What advice does Broyles give parents if Child Protective Services shows up at their door? “Without a warrant or court order, you do not talk to them. You do not let your child talk to them. You should absolutely not let them interview your child with or without you. You don’t let them into your home, you don’t let them into your car. You don’t let them into your hospital room if you’re there in the hospital, you don’t let them into the room with you if you’re in a doctor’s office. You don’t let them in without a warrant or a court order, regardless of what they say. Because once they’re in they will take whatever you say or your child says and potentially use it against you. And then the next thing you know, there’s a possibility that they go to a court, to a judge, ex parte, and get a court order to remove your child. That’s distinctly possible.” Following up on Ahmed’s family, I spoke with Syed’s therapist, an autism expert, to find out how he has been doing since moving with his parents and sister out of Washington. She confirmed what Syed’s father told me: Syed is no longer suicidal, nor does he believe he is transgender. As a 17-year-old autistic boy, he shows startlingly advanced intellectual development and in social realms, can seem quite childish: He’s doing advanced work in philosophy, she tells me—and also remains fascinated by his sister’s My Little Ponies. That’s more than okay with his mom and dad.

  • TReVoices - Parents/Detrans

    TReVoices Is The Leading Org Fighting To Stop Childhood Medical Transition World Wide! ​ Led by transman/lesbian Scott Newgent, our relentless SCREAMING to 'STOP Medically Transitioning Children' has been and continues to be heard everyday World - Wide! Make sure we can continue - We Need Your Help - Donate Today. Button Lift The Veil. Parents Get Busy & Learn Why 'Medical Transition Is Not Place For a child.' Sincerely, TReVoices & Everyone Else < Back Laura A. Original Article Detrans Voices Laura is 37 and currently resides in Austria Laura Detrans Journey Detrans Story: Laura I was born in 1983, and as I sit writing this, I am 36 years old. I am female. I have always been female, but for nearly a decade, starting in my mid-teens, I was in denial of this fact. I took drastic measures to conceal it, including testosterone injections starting at age 18, a double mastectomy shortly after my 20th birthday, and cumulating in a second surgery on my chest, which was supposed to correct the poor aesthetic outcome of the first surgery. Instead, it was so badly botched that it threw me into a crisis which fortunately led to my detransitioning, although this word did not exist at that time. I was, for all intents and purposes, in uncharted territory. In retrospect, I am glad that I experienced this wake-up call when I did, and did not remain on testosterone any longer. Unbeknownst to me at the time, the testosterone had caused me to develop vaginal and uterine atrophy, which led in part to a pelvic organ prolapse , which I will be dealing with for the rest of my life. If I had remained on testosterone longer, and my pelvic organ prolapse had been diagnosed while I was still under the care of gender doctors, I think it is very likely that I would have ended up having a hysterectomy. Today , as the mother of a toddler age son, I am very grateful that I did not lose my fertility. At the time, though, it was impossible for me to imagine any kind of future for myself. All I knew was that I could not follow the transgender path any longer. At the turn of the millennium, at the age of 16, when I declared myself to be a “gay male”, changed my name, and socially transitioned, the transgender “community”, and society at large, were different than today. I did not know any other teenagers who were “transitioning”, so I was not subjected to social contagion, nor was I exposed to the idea that I had possibly been “born in the wrong body” or could “change my sex” through children´s books, television, or a seminar on “gender identity” at school. I was not a feminine girl. At age 8 I was diagnosed with ADHD and put on a lot of medication which did not help me. I remember reading an article which claimed that the diagnosis of ADHD was pathologizing normal young boys, whose brains had supposedly been shaped by evolution to be quite different from those of young girls, and at this point, it occurred to me for the first time that I might actually have a “boy´s brain”. Fortunately, this was not affirmed by my psychiatrist at the time. If I had been born later, I think it´s likely that I would have become a pediatric transitioner. I was socially ostracized by my peers, and in my early teens my parents’ house was repeatedly the target of vandals who spray painted slurs like “lesbo”. For a time, I actually wished that I could have been a lesbian, because I thought this would have provided me with an explanation for my difference, and some hope of finding acceptance and maybe love. I already knew that I could not be a lesbian though, because I was not attracted to women. At this time, the internet still consisted largely of text-based message boards and MtFs still greatly outnumbered FtMs. I found information about transsexuality online, and although it had all been written by MtFs, I knew immediately that this was what I wanted. I researched passing tips, cut my hair, and found it surprisingly easy to pass as male, at least among people who did not already know me. Not long after that I dropped out of school, a year later I was hitchhiking and freight hopping around the United States, sleeping in abandoned buildings. In San Francisco, in spring of 2002, when I was 18 years old, I started testosterone at what was then apparently one of the few clinics which specifically catered to “trans youth”, and where, although an interview with a psychiatrist was conducted, neither heterosexuality, nor an obviously dysfunctional life, were considered barriers to transition. The clinicians were activists. They affirmed everyone. It was a microcosm of what exists almost everywhere today. The trans ideology which I internalized at this time, and helped to spread, had just emerged, and I was one of its early and enthusiastic adopters. I loved the way testosterone made me feel at first. I was stronger and more energetic, so I imagined it was actually improving my health, and that I had been something like a eunuch before I started taking it. I believed that transition was the only effective treatment for gender dysphoria, and that those who could not transition, or who “failed” at transition, inevitably committed suicide. Based on assurances from the “trans community” that transition presented my only chance of survival, the implication that friends and family who questioned my transition did not care if I died, while in reality deeply paranoid, had seemed logical. I had been encouraged to sever ties with anyone and everyone who refused to affirm and support my transition, and I had. I then found myself isolated in the echo chamber which I had constructed, unable to voice my own doubts when they arose. There were multiple times during the 5 or so years of my medical transition where I questioned where all this was taking me, but I could not bear to get honest with myself, let alone to get honest with the friends and family members who I had manipulated into enabling my self-destruction. I felt very conflicted in the days and weeks leading up to my first chest surgery, but was afraid to back out because my parents had already paid for it, and according to the “trans community”, this made me privileged. I felt that all eyes were on me, and that it would be easier to go through with the surgery than to come up with an explanation for backing out last minute which did not cast transition in a bad light, making it harder for other people to “access care”. This dynamic repeated itself even more dramatically before my second chest surgery. The same voices, internal and external, which had originally assured me that “top surgery” was no big deal, and would result in a beautiful male appearing chest, now told me that a “revision” was necessary to fix the prominent scarring, asymmetry, and itchy puss filled nipple grafts. My desperate attempts to convince myself and others that my chest was beautiful and that I was happy with my surgical results had failed. Again and again I was told that another surgeon could “fix” my chest, if I would only let them. I had been made to understand that it was unacceptable for trans people who had been harmed by botched surgeries or the side effects of hormone treatments to express regret or talk openly about their experiences, because this threw the emerging transgender medical industry into disrepute, and would result in other trans people being denied these supposedly “lifesaving treatments”. It was not permitted to acknowledge the unsatisfactory results of the first surgery, without committing to undergoing a second surgery. However implausible the second surgeon’s promises may have sounded, I had to believe that they could magically undo the misfortune of my first surgery, thus restoring my reputation, and the reputation of medical transition in general, which were both called into question by my very existence as a trans person with a publicly botched surgery. Faith in the transformative power of scalpels and needles had to be maintained against all odds. The ideal of the triumph of the will over the flesh had no alternative. My motto at the time may as well have been “victory or death”. After my second botched surgery, as the reality of a concave chest, permanently poor posture, nerve pain, and recurrent episodes of numbness and paralysis in my arm, sunk in, it was impossible to maintain the illusion any longer. In a state of desperation, I consulted a third surgeon, who suggested silicone “pec implants”. It became glaringly obvious that medical transition did not have the power to transform me into a male and could only destroy me. I had once loudly advocated for “trans rights”, and against “gatekeeping” and the requirement to wait until turning 18 to begin medical transition. Now, at 23 years of age, I found myself mutilated and voiceless. I was “collateral damage”. I contemplated suicide. It seemed that my only option was to disappear. I stopped taking testosterone, and I became addicted, first to prescription painkillers, and then to heroin. Eventually I came to two realizations: firstly, that I needed to stop harming my body, whether through transition, through drugs, or whatever. I would probably be alive a long time, whether I liked it or not, and the unhealthier I made myself, seeking to avoid suffering, the more I would actually have to suffer. Secondly, that I needed to take accountability for my actions, because my self-destructive behavior was not merely self-destructive, but rather the direct and indirect cause of harm to others, often through the glamorization of self-destructive behavior, which seemed to come naturally to me. When I got clean, I was fortunate to get support from other recovering addicts who shared their experience, strength and hope with me, and showed me by example that another way of life was possible, even for those, like myself, who had plumbed the depths of depravity. The first step was getting honest with myself, and I did. I became aware of the myriad ways in which my unwillingness to accept reality, and my struggle to manipulate reality, which I had once regarded as necessary, and even as heroic, had resulted in my descent to ever increasing levels of hopelessness and despair. This awareness, and the belief that another way of life was possible, restored me to sanity. I had been relieved of a colossal burden, the belief that I had to control everyone and everything in order to survive, but life for me as a detransitioned woman was not always easy. Not only did I have ongoing health problems as a result of the harm that medical transition had done to my body, but my deep voice and lack of breasts caused me to stick out from other females, resulting in me sometimes being mistaken for a transwoman. The difference was that, unlike when I was attempting to “live as male”, I did not inflate these experiences and allow them to occupy every waking moment of my life. I found that it was possible to practice self-acceptance, even while still experiencing regret. Despite my desire to find a man, fall in love, and start a family of my own, I discovered that the changes I had made to my body had rendered me unattractive to most men. Those few men who were attracted to me often had pedophile tendencies or other paraphilias, such as an amputation fetish. For this reason, I remained single, and largely celibate. It is possible that even if I had not transitioned, that I would have been unable to find a husband because of my poor social skills, but I will never know. One thing I have come to understand is that I have no control over the past, and that it is pointless to speculate over “alternative timelines” which do not exist. Freed from the self-obsession which had dominated my life in my trans days, I was able to pursue things outside myself which were infinitely more interesting, such as teaching myself German, reading lots of books, including medieval literature, and especially Icelandic sagas, developing an appreciation of obscure baroque era composers, and learning to identify all of the flowering plants native to the Washington, D.C. Metropolitan Area while photographing them in their natural habitats. Several years ago, I noticed that the transgender ideology was no longer a fringe phenomenon, as it had been when I first encountered it, and in retrospect still was when I escaped it. Not only was it becoming omnipresent in the mainstream media, but many people who I had previously told of my traumatic experience with transition, who had reacted sympathetically at the time, were now being reeducated to think that it was bigoted to bring the “triumphal narrative” of transition into question, the way I did by simply talking about my own experiences. Some tried to pressure me into identifying as “non-binary”, others suggested that I attend a “transgender support group” when the subject of my chronic health problems came up. I felt support being quietly withdrawn. I was on the defensive. I felt put on the spot when people would ask for my pronouns, or otherwise go out of their way to imply that they assumed I must somehow be transgender. I did not know how to deal with this. I thought that I had more or less successfully managed to leave this chapter of my life in the past, but now it seemed to have caught up with me. It was for this reason, in part, that I made the decision to leave the US, where I had been born, raised, and had all my experiences with transition and detransition. I remained here in Austria after visiting in the summer of 2015, because I believed the transgender ideology to be a uniquely American phenomenon, and I naively assumed that things here were different. Unfortunately, I was wrong. The transgender ideology may be largely a US invention, but it has been exported and adopted worldwide. I started to notice things changing around me, over the course of a few years, symbols of the transgender ideology began to appear on the streets of Vienna, first as graffiti, then as signs in store windows. When I was pregnant with my son and attempting to find breast milk donors for him online, I discovered that many women active in the “alternative” mother scene online in Germany and Austria were raising their toddler age children as transgender, and that any other mothers who dared to question the wisdom of this were swept away in a flood of criticism. I was appalled. At the same time, I learned that many people who prided themselves on being supportive of “trans rights”, including the insistence that young children should be allowed to determine their own “gender” and then be placed on a medical pathway before puberty if their chosen “gender” happened to clash with their “assigned sex”, were in reality so ignorant of the primitive state of transgender medicine that they actually believed the doctors would be able to change the children´s sexes. They did not understand that “sex change” is a trans medical industry propagated myth, and what actually occurs is cosmetic surgery, which can go very wrong, and even best-case scenario results in infertility and lifelong dependence on medication. Multiple people who I interacted with while pregnant, including some who worked in social services or in doctors’ offices, believed that I was a transwoman, despite the fact that they knew I was pregnant. How could this be? I realized that the apparent adoption of science and reason as guiding principles by current societies was extremely fragile and superficial. Under the surface teemed a bottomless sea of medieval superstition. Most people were not engaging in scientific thinking, but merely passively accepting as truth whatever claims were made by credible seeming authorities, and these messages were rapidly being corrupted by ideology. Last winter I stumbled upon a word that I had never seen before online, and that word was “detransitioner”. For the first time, I saw other women, younger than myself, who had been through something like what I had been through, and were talking about it publicly, at a panel in Great Britain. I reached out to some of them online. After all of those years, I was thrilled to no longer be alone with my experience, but quickly I realized that these brave young women, who had found the courage to speak about their experiences, were only the tip of the iceberg. Over the past few years, while I had been preoccupied with trying to get pregnant, being pregnant, crying over not being able to breastfeed, and caring for a baby, the number of young people, particularly girls, who were medically transitioning had skyrocketed. This had resulted in a building tsunami of regret, which trans activists were doing their best to suppress, terrified that detrans people sharing their experiences would call the triumphal narrative of transition into question. For over a decade I had suffered with the knowledge that my early trans activism and promotion of transition to my peers had resulted in harm to many individuals, damage which I could never undo. Now an opportunity to do an indirect amends had fallen into my lap, and I knew that I was morally obligated to act on it. Soon after I made a twitter account and posted a few videos on YouTube, talking about my story. After all those years, I finally found my voice . Laura is 37 and currently resides in Austria. You can find her YouTube channel here: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC0PzPV2-mrkbxLPk2-eY53Q Twitter: @FlohrFritz

  • TReVoices - SCREAMING In The Media

    < Back With Congressman Dan Crenshaw & trans Man Scott Newgent "Let's Talk About Transgenderism...Debate" Scott Newgent US https://youtu.be/NDXAKXPlsdg Original Link

  • TReVoices - SCREAMING In The Media

    < Back Ativista trans se manifesta contra as políticas de gênero de Joe Biden Leia mais em: Trans activist speaks out against Joe Biden's gender policies By, Madeleine Kearns & Scott Newgent Brazil ​ Original Link

Transman
Scott Newgent

Follow Scott @NotScottNewgent

bottom of page